Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

[Mantis]

Just haven’t wanted to type too much on mobile re screenplay vote. Can later

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

Here:

andres could be scum

As does this. Really? Not even a broader case to make here? Why am I Scum? It’s a complete throwaway remark and totally unsubstantiated by anything you’ve said all game.

No response.

Andres was still on my short list for today

I’m interested to know why you thought this. So I was bussing my Scum buddy D1?

I actually didn’t have time to look at your iso much so I guess that probably accounted for it too.

This isn’t backtracking?

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

But then Andres claims to need to collect all the fragments? (an Orb Collector/Thief/Emissary), and he mentions being “aligned with the Wormhole Entities”, nowhere listed in the Sample Role PM, but claimg those are the Prophets.

I don’t need to collect all the fragments. I would have failed at this already given that _fferyllt had one (that might have been taken or not, I don’t know actually). I also gain an ability once I collect an Orb, though there’s no mention of finding the right Orb, which I found interesting about Josh’s claim.

And yes the Wormhole Entities are the Prophets. It’s just an alternative name for them.

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

VC 3-4

Screenplay: 2 (Urist, Mantis)
Josh: 1 (Metal Sonic)
pyx: 1 (Judge Mental)

Not voting: 5 (srceenplay, Catspurr, Josh, pyx, Mantis)

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline: September 7, 2018 4:00 AM

This topic will close automatically 30 minutes after the deadline.

Mod Notes:

• Josh v/la

Links
Day 1 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 2 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 3 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

[MetalSonic]

I visit the sick bay to get my medical condition checked.

[Urist]

[MetalSonic]

is that a comedy? declaring bankruptcy is bad for your health… but so is being in debt…

[Mantis]

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

nah, I had for a second where I thought maybe he was. That passed pretty quickly. Let’s take it one step at a time. I’m tired of over thinking it too much. Perhaps Josh and cabd could work?

[Mantis]

Actually came on intending to look at cats posts that I thought looked town, but then ended up looking at interactions or any references with Nanook or cabd … I decided to keep it out of spoiler, because in spoiler, you would have to click on the links.

So, I’m gonna take another look at this. …I think it could possibly work. No firm vote on Nanook, or hammer on cabd. Lots of back and forth with Nanook though, and inferring that he is scum. And lots of announcing that it is either cabd or MS. Essentially ends in cabd, but then vote was removed.

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

@Nanook mass claiming is bullshit. It totally undermines the whole point of the game. Why do you want to fuck up the GM? Unless you mean just saying who we are, which I am happy to do, because I am thrilled by my character. But that is not going to tell us anything because scum always have false claims.

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

I disagree on so many things you say nanook. Town don’t Have to say why they are changing votes. But town explaining to town why they are voting where they are voting is an expected part of the game and often is reason to vote for them when they don’t explain.

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

His vote is on you isn’t it? Of course you are not going to like it. Do you think I like your vote on me? Shit happens :shrug:

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

Which thinking about it, probably puts Metal Sonic higher on my scum list than Nanook who I very may well be just OMGUSing

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

your the one who outed it. VOTE:NANOOK

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

What purpose would srceen have to false claim so early in the game? It makes no sense as scum, town or even indie to claim so early or to clear me if he was fake claiming. I mean, why me? If he is Scum he knows I’m not, but he doesn’t know my role, my powers if any or even if I am town. For all he knows I am indie. The only reason I can think of to fake claim so early is if we are scum on the same team? But so early? When neither of us was under threat? When, if either of us are lynched,…

changes to Screen

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

Okay, I’ll bite. Lets lynch Srceenplay and see what shite is happening. VOTE: SRCEENPLAY

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

I see nanook as possible scum. srceenplay asked me to vote nanook with me, so I did. Why not? I can move my vote around as much as I want. Admittly using your vote means a lot more in plurality games than these abominations of majority lynch.

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

For someone who is not suppose to have enough time to play you sure hang around like a bad smell. Still 7 days to go, SEVEN days. With you barking and nipping around like a very annoying dog. So? If I;m scum, who are my scum mates? Have you given us a list of your reads?

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

There are no specifics, I have seen this before. Scum chose someone to Tunnel Track the whole game and no one calls them out on it. Perrrfffeect way to hide as scum. VOTE: NANOOK

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

Okay, I have actually said why I am seeing you as scummy above and beyond the fact that I see you style as scummy. You are placing a lot on a Meta read claim that is, his attitude is different, he is distancing himself. But when other people express their opinion based on their own many years of experience you belittle it, you put it down, and you are insulting. But of course, if you percieve people as insulting you, once again you start belittling disrepecting them and putting thme down. Tha…

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

It is very unfortunate that cabd is out of wifi range, Really need a lot more osts from them. I had skitter as a slight town lean but not liking cabd as much. Not as keen on lynching Josh as I might have been. Would like to give Metal more time. If I am tunnel tracking on nanook rather than the other way around, I could be talked into voting cabd. As pointed out, his vote on Josh does not have a lot of explanation to it. I better ISO them. Won’t be much.

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

On reread cabd looks better than he did except for his fly in fly out vote on Josh. Maybe just picking the biggest wagon because? Least effort? Believes lynch is better than no lynch? Scum jumping on a bandwagon?

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

I could almost get on a CABD lynch. But liked skitter for town and it is only CABD last post/vote that looks a bit scummy before they disappeared. Smilodon is occupied in RL. She could be scum she often is, but want to give her more time get back into the game or ask to be replaced. Is anyone interested in my case against Nanook? He is Tunnel Tracking Lying tricksy trister scum.:ohyes:

This switch appeared town to me (from my pov)

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

This is where I started seeing Mantis as town. Fuck it is so hard to remember all the days play that I am ISOing my self. No, not voting for Mantis today.

bit odd (since cats is not voting Nanook at this point, but sees him as scum

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

@Mental are you scummy buddies with Nanook?

would have hammered cabd… didn’t though…

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

I’m reading along. I am so in two minds about srceenplay, could be scum but their scum game was more aggressive and over the top when I played with them. But claiming there fake claim sorted nanook is total bullshit to me because I don’t remember them even voting nanook with me. Another one of those damned players who pat themselves on the back AFTER the fact? I would like to sort cabd, srceenplay and mental. Want a LOT more posting from cabd. I could have hammered him yesterday but wanted …

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

He aksed me rather pointedly why I didn’t hammer cabd. I said I was early town reading skitter and was thinking no lynch was a better option and then when the smilo wagon got rolling I kinda got over excited and jumped on. In my defense I had a slight town read on cabd. Was very neutral on smilo, and have very leary about Smilos scum game. It is amazing how often she rands scum.

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

UNVOTE: UNVOTE;METAL SONIC VOTE: VOTE:CABD. Put up or Shut up CABD

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

There seems to be something in th water. Everyone is full of diarrhea I would love to just vote Metal on CABD say so, but CABD has squirmed so much I fear they are a worm, a scummy worm. So let us then lynch cabd, as their claim is obviously fake? But no, Metal has wiggled enough to appear like a caught fish unapple to spit out the worm & hook. So, maybe cabd is a genuine town angler. UNVOTE: UNVOTE:CABD

post 2347 - post 2616 (quite a few back and forth on either MS or CABD - saying one of them is scum)

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

I’m very sorry Metal, but I think you are the one who needs to be sorted. VOTE: METAL SONIC

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

UNVOTE: METAL

back to MS

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

After you fake claiming a cop role day one? Then trying it on again? And yes I know you where joking. If your role PM went out of it’s way to say that an investigation of you or who you protected would return both of you, then there is very definitely an investigative role. Would a tracker role return something like that? CABD says they tracked Metal to _fferyltt So if they had chosen you or pyx they would have had a return of srceen visited pyx or pyx was visited by srceen. But that woul…

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

VOTE: VOTE:METAL SONIC Till they come and purr and hiss at me and I cave in again.

2nd vote on Cabd after MS (about 12 hours previously there was a cabd wagon that disbanded)

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

UNVOTE: **METAL** VOTE: **CABD**

cats says

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

Lets even up the wagons and see what that shakes out of the woodwork.

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

One thing in favour of a CABD lynch over a Metal is that Metal has been involved in the game since they were in danger. CABD hasn’t been here either way.

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

I was hoping this might end before I went out. But it does not matter. I have decided to leave my vote on CABD. Now, what is happening? Judge?

Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3

I have to go out. I will probably be back in under three hours. UNVOTE: CABD I will leave my vote as a none vote.

That’s the end of day 2

[Mantis]

But ya, my vote was on Screenplay, @Andresvmb - because at the time, I had read over pyx and cats, and thought they were town. Urist & Judge are town -> I feel certain on that, just through meta. I think MS is probably town (I still have very minor worries, just due to his secrecy and whatnot). And possibly going through a game plan with cabd scum to see what the best tactic would be to win - go after the other. Cabd didn’t even go after him though; (which alarms me a bit). But, overall I think MS has acted towny. For instance - he doesn’t have to give pyx a town pass. He could easily be pushing on pyx, as scum.

Josh I have a few concerns on, because again, there’s a bit of not knowing exactly what his role is. Him having to look for something. … will continue in a moment

[Mantis]

Baby woke up from nap after 30 minutes… which is not enough time, she needs to sleep longer. Lulled her back to sleep …successfully ?

I’m actually just gonna ISO Josh, to get that out of the way, so I can decide what I think.

[Mantis]

Lulled her back to sleep …successfully ?

Nevermind !

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

Should have answered me! I have a hard time following all these side conversations, though I try and read everything.

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

I can’t clear Urist through meta as I haven’t played with him enough, but you need to think harder about what he’s done and where he has lead us to, because it does not look good. You’ll notice that he was the only strong proponent of avoiding Cabd/MS. And he could have hammered Cabd, but he decided to lead the Smilodon lynch together with Nanook, who is confirmed Scum. If this was me, I know you guys would be voting for me.

[Urist]

just bonk her on the head, should put her right back to sleep

[pyx]

Now I wanna be lulled back to sleep.

[Urist]

you need to think harder about what he’s done and where he has lead us to

the only place i led you to is a world where we lynched cabd instead of MS.
what can i say except “you’re welcome?”

[catspurr]

We can NOT lynch Srceen. Their claim has to much cred when there was no kill.
We can NOT lynch Metal, scum cabd would NOT have set up scum Metal.

I think Metal is being possessed to do the kills.
I think Metal did kill _fferyllt, but was possessed doing it.
AND
I think Metal was possessed to kill Srceenplay and failed because Srceenplay is immune.

What evidence?
Well, the Doctor claimed Yesterday, when it was not really nesseccary.
AND when it was obvious they would be the Night Killed.
THEN there is no Night Kill.

If this was a FAKE claim, how did scum KNOW there is NOT another Doctor?
Tracker was risky enough, but Doctor?
To my mind it is the least likely of all the claims to be false.

[Urist]

Ftr at this point I’m just gonna keep voting Srceen until he claims Hider.

[Mental (Judge)]

…below is lifted from pyx’s post Deep Space 9 Mafia - Day 3 and I’m taking the bulk of it to be correct (i.e. the claims part)

there was a Mafia Goon and a Mafia 2-shot Roleblocker.

• pyx claims miller and has said he expects both a godfather and an alignment cop. Pyx also claims 2-shot BG. Pyx agrees that miller without alignment cop does not make sense - responding to urist’s race cop claim. Does this combination of claims - remembering pyx’s predecessor made the initial miller claim immediately D1 - make any sense, given pyx himself is saying there must/should be roles matching miller. Do his claims make any balance sense?? Pyx also said that MS is perhaps linking his role to urist’s which I don’t recall… @Urist? @MetalSonic ?
• MS is claiming some amazing PR that scum apparently are so scared of they have blocked him every night. Is this OK with everyone?
• urist is claiming race cop with a block N1 and view of judge N2 which revealed something that made sense to him, I’ve nfi . He’s claiming he was blocked N1
• screen’s latest claim is doc and he and his target Andres were both protected N2
• josh is claiming an Object Finder that gains an ability if/when he finds the right thing. Judge has confirmed his N2 action and mantis his N1 action. Could he possibly be scum? Anyone? …Bueller ?
• judge - VT and confirms josh’s night action to take the bauble-y thing
• cats claims VT with a fixation on the neighbouriser mechanic. Is this true? @catspurr - do yo claim VT?
• Andres has claimed if he collected the right orb he’d gain an ability…so…VT? @Andresvmb can you confirm?
• mantis claims VT and confirms N1 josh’s action

do this many VTs in this game make sense?

doesn’t bodyguard mean that there is someone whose protect/targeting combination result in the bodyguard’s death? (I’m rusty or plain incompetent with this stuff)

so…as it stands on claims, either pyx is lying about being a miller and likely has the prostitute role that has amused MS both nights, or urist is lying and has the prostitute role

I want to flip pyx as that will sort urist. I think. @Urist why are you not honing on on pyx?

…anyone want to weigh in?