Josh: 4 (Urist, Metal Sonic, Andresvmb, Cabd)
Urist has decided you’re scum, so I’m not surprised by that vote. MS seems to be kidding around and/or I don’t know what they are doing. At all. Andres… I don’t recall a case building on you from them. I’d have to ISO, which I dread to do because that would mean re-reading most of the thread*. CABD is another I don’t recall seeing any case building, either.
I can see a wagon on you being able to hide scum with the townies who think you’re toxic town.
*sorry Andres! If I were reading your posts ‘live’ I’m sure I’d not take you to task for wordiness.
It’s true that I think your game is generally scummy. You are on my scum list, however, because I don’t like what I’m seeing between you and Nanook. It’s not like you to be this way with a player. Also, your vote on screen was very weird. There does seem to be something different about your game this game. How thrown have you been, if at all, by being fake-claimed as town cleared?
I’m not voting you because your town game is also scummy, to me. I want to see what Nanook (assuming they are town) are seeing that is different. It would be good info to have for future games, as well.
What is interesting is that you say you are leaning ‘slight town’ on me. As crappy a player as I am, those who know my game should find me me obvtown. If you and the others don’t reward my earnest town game I’m going to be peeved. Peeved.
It is very unfortunate that cabd is out of wifi range,
Really need a lot more osts from them.
I had skitter as a slight town lean but not liking cabd as much.
Not as keen on lynching Josh as I might have been.
Would like to give Metal more time.
If I am tunnel tracking on nanook rather than the other way around, I could be talked into voting cabd.
As pointed out, his vote on Josh does not have a lot of explanation to it.
I better ISO them.
Won’t be much.
I was thrown by srceenplay not because he cleared me.
I would expect that but with the night 0 claim.
Things did happen in Night Zero or at least there is a back story.
Then everyone is saying, and screen seems to be saying it was a fake claim.
I don’t want to say anything more about N0 today.
I did not like his walls of post.
But then Andre pointed out that he found them towny and worth reading.
So I ISO’d him and read through it all.
Tha is a few days ago now so don’t remember exactly what if any post tipped me to a town lean, but I ended up having a town read on them.
ISO’d cabd and I have changed my mind on not likeing their posts.
They were a bit out there but not really alignment indicative.
So have gone back to my town lean except for the Josh vote.
I have pointed out the possible reasons for the Josh vote and hope they have time to come back and tell us more.
um…scum…I was scum in these two but they aren’t mafia, as such:
I haven’t been scum in a proper mafia game for a long time. Not at all on this site, thank god, as I hate rolling scum. I think this is the last game I rolled scum: http://talkrational.org/index.php/topic,1764.0.html but if anyone else can think of anything more recent please let me know.
I won’t disagree that @_fferyllt has been somewhat coasting. I ISO’d him, and I can’t say that my Town lean is justified. He seems to be probing at Nanook’s view of Cats without truly saying much about it, and was amongst the first to express that Cats’ question about who his Scum mates would be was NAI:
So, he’s probably not the same alignment as Nanook, and perhaps same alignment as Cats. It’s difficult to say though stand-alone if he’s Town or not. So I’ll move him down my pecking order.
You know what piqued my interest? The reasoning. Cabd makes a comment saying that Josh was looking for a new target. But that’s not true. Josh had been arguing for an MS lynch for a while. That’s what I felt was rather strange.
VC 1-37