Back to VOTE: Catspurr
I think the frustration is genuine, but I’m uncomfortable tea leaf reading to the level that would make it AI. So I’m left with my meta read of them, which is still valid I believe.
Reason for Josh as scum beyond “he’s annoying?”
Also, can we agree that AD’s lurking was NAI at this point?
no
well actually the lurking itself doesn’t matter
that’s has nothing to do with why he might be scum though
what meta read?
i remember you mentioning this but i don’t remember you going into specifics
There are no specifics, I have seen this before.
Scum chose someone to Tunnel Track the whole game and no one calls them out on it.
Perrrfffeect way to hide as scum.
VOTE: NANOOK
Ok—why is he scum then?
You know there are specifics, though.
Short version is that Cats consciously restrains himself as scum, and I’m picking up on that distance throughout this game. When you know what you’re looking for, it stands in stark contrast to their town style.
Judge Mental replaces ActionDan. Please welcome them!
the most recent post looks towny, does it not?
like what?
i said why i think he’s scum some time earlier (whenever cabd asked about it)
nothing to do with his lurking and everything to do with what he actually posted. him flaking isn’t exactly encouraging either, though!
the AD stuff isn’t a read and isn’t even really accurate (even if smilodon doesn’t lurk as scum, so what?). catspurr read isn’t exactly stellar reasoning either. unsure where the town part of that post is
Maybe you’re right and I’m wrong! I guess I didn’t put that much thought into my read!
Do you think smilodon is scum?
Btw, scum usually don’t have daytalk in these longass games. That’s part of what makes it so hard to keep your head above water as scum in these games.
not a thing
This is incorrect with this mod’s meta.
Assume all potential factions or roles with out-of-thread talk have it at all times day and night.