Triple Tickle Game Thread (Day 4)

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

@GoldenGirl

Oh also I like transparency, so I’m revealing that Phone invited me to this game :>

Then I should note that I was invited here by the host, Seth. Idk anyone else here.

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

@Spak

Anyone who gets on (or Sam if you come back tonight): if you were the Specialist, how do you think you’d use it?

I would do the heart-rate thing. I believe an alignment check is much more powerful. Of course, it can be misleading a bit, but towns will be aware of that if a specialist reveals their checks. I mean, unless you accidentally clear 2 killers (I’m thinking at most 1), then you should be able to help clear the game massively especially if those high heart-rate checks manage to live to the end.

The other abilities are quite nuanced and I think its only useful if you have a good possible solve anyways, so I would still use the other ability first as that would help with the solve.

[GoldenGirl (Sam)]

I’m gonna say this Spak - if my actions have been towny, it’s smarter to townread them first and then reconsider later. The only thing I’ll say is that unpredictableness is something that will happen no matter what day you catch me on, and not to BRAG, but trying to 1ynch someone who’s been inherently towny is just going to flat out stall the game.

[GoldenGirl (Sam)]

That being said, hello Martin! Hopefully you have something nice to contribute

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

@Luftwaffle

I don’t like this, nor do I like the townread on Spak “for being nice” (which is a terrible reason to read someone) in #28. It looks like you want to appear towny, perhaps a little bit too hard. VOTE: GoldenGirl

This pings hard. Picks out a specific post, rather than saying anything constructive or overall. Also vague.

Also, you say shes trying to look town “too hard”, but why aren’t you reacting to her posts that, apparently have a lot of effort put into them (Such as maybe #47 or #61)? I mean, by definition you’re saying she’s giving a lot of effort into this, but then you’re not really reacting to that high-effort content and not only that you give a really vague discredit of “trying too hard to look town”?

VOTE: Luftwaffle

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

Like, I almost want to not consider anyone else for D1 just because of how bad I think that comment or post was.

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

@GoldenGirl

That being said, hello Martin! Hopefully you have something nice to contribute

Turns out I do but if Luftwaffle is town I hope I see something better from him as I read on

I really hated that entrance; I tend to value entrances and the early game as they can show a mindset and whether its villagery or not. Of course, it can be faked, but sometimes that is difficult for people to do.

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

@Benedict

Me too

wait what you’re here oberon

okay I retract what I said here I know this guy but everyone else I don’t know.

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

I’m going to lean on Andres’ entrance being likely town.

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

@GoldenGirl

You’re reading based off of something that is solely NAI.

You’ve been told this multiple times.

You aren’t listening, which leads me to believe you aren’t trying to progress town’s wincon.

Is this an excuse to execute someone you think is being anti-town?

I’m going to be realistic here. I don’t think scum Andres is persistent like that. All scum have 1 life y’know, whereas in the typical or original kind of mafia game with like 12 players means mafia have 3 lives so one of them going down doesn’t matter as much, thus meaning they’re less self-conscious on D1. Here, that’s different. They have 1 life, and they can lose 48 hours into the game.

[Seththeking (TrueSoulEnergy)]

Tickle Count

(2) LuftWaffle - MartinGG99, ErikaFurudo
(1) ErikaFurudo - Phone0Ix
(1) GoldenGirl - LuftWaffle
(1) Phone0Ix - Andresvmb
(1) ExquisiteCrab - Spak
Not Voting - GoldenGirl, Benedict, ExquisiteCrab

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

@Luftwaffle

…rl isn’t a tryhard scum then, but it’s not like nobody ever lied in a game of Mafia, so I’m not convinced. We’ll see when there’s a more clear AI intent coming from her.
I agree heart rate is a better choice when 3 killers are alive. As for roleblock vs heal (which should likely be kept for when we got at least 1 killer down), it all depends on whether there is an obvious townie that’s gonna get killed or suspicious people. About Spak asking what the Specialist should do, I originally thought it was about in which order he would make killers kill. Saying what you’d do as Specialist would put the real Specialist in a small PoE for the killer based on the fact that he knows his own role was first in the list. That’s what I was opposed to. The more standard actions don’t really hurt to discuss.

And his 2nd post in the thread (unless I missed one) is solely consisting of slightly backing off on that claim of Golden being scum

and then finally joining the specialist action discussion.

Still bad imo. I don’t see anything shining towniness here, as he still hasn’t talked about anyone else really in-depth 223 posts into the game. I hardly see him solving here, nor having the energy to solve.

[ErikaFurudo (Hustlevania)]

@GoldenGirl

Genuinely wouldn’t be surprised if Erika flipped killer rn

@GoldenGirl

I hold people to a higher standard than one liner spam and if you aren’t going to fulfill it then I really have no choice - I’m not going to read nor try to read the unreadable

These may not be lies, but you aren’t denying it

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

@Spak

but I think I trust Luft/Benedict most out of everyone who’s posted so far (in the little I’ve seen from them).

???
Mind giving your thoughts on Benedict at least? I don’t think you’ll change my mind about Luft

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

Also yes I did just skip 100 posts

I have no interest in that Andres - Golden - Spak convo because I think all 3 have decent or good chances to be town.

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

@Spak

I’ll also say - I’ve found that people who are playing as scum tend to rely more heavily on self-meta, as they’re constantly thinking about how to emulate it. Certainly not a sure-fire thing, but it’s something that’s worth mentioning.

Considering how many times Golden has been brought up, questioned, or mentioned in the thread so far

Isn’t it kind inevitable for that sort of topic or thing to appear?

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

Okay so to sum it up the first 200 posts or so was interesting

the last 150 or so posts were relatively boring

[GoldenGirl (Sam)]

@MartinGG99

Is this an excuse to execute someone you think is being anti-town?

I’m going to be realistic here. I don’t think scum Andres is persistent like that. All scum have 1 life y’know, whereas in the typical or original kind of mafia game with like 12 players means mafia have 3 lives so one of them going down doesn’t matter as much, thus meaning they’re less self-conscious on D1. Here, that’s different. They have 1 life, and they can lose 48 hours into the game.

Yeah I’ve said Andres is probably town, I just hate his playstyle ngl

[GoldenGirl (Sam)]

@ErikaFurudo

These may not be lies, but you aren’t denying it

Am I going to have to babysit you? Seriously, what kind of argument is “You aren’t denying it!!!” when there was nothing to deny in the first place?

[MartinGG99 (AKA That one Idiot)]

@Seththeking

@MartinGG99
@Benedict
@ExquisiteCrab
@Luftwaffle
@ErikaFurudo
@Phone0Ix
@Spak
@Andresvmb
@GoldenGirl

–Town–
(Me)
Spak
Andresvmb
GoldenGirl

–Unkown–
Benedict
Exquisite Crab
Erika
Phone0Ix

–Killers–
Luftwaffle