lynching me may not be such a terrible idea after all.
for me, not for you guys. it’ll be really terrible for town. but i want to relax. this is insane mode mafia
to be entirely fair i havent been putting in a quarter the amount of effort as pyx is though. he actually went back to re read the game and to corroborate andres’s claim? wow!
but i am certainly keeping extremely up-to-date and active with the thread
i think urist and andres has the biggest potential to be snekky sneks
There’s that. But also why push screen sooo hard and then say he will gladly eat 1000 lynches if he comes up scum? That’s more idiotic town… kind of like in my situation. It’s almost just too dumb for scum to do.
Then I guess there’s also the fact of… what would be the point of having a scum racecop?
Srceen, in the eyes of Scum, could not be NK’ed (confirmed, since there was no NK and was probably targeted), and was also the Town Doctor (and given his claim, potentially an unlimited amount of times). Would you not risk the game to get that player lynched?
I’ve been thinking about it on and off… even when not in thread. Actually not long ago… and was thinking about what I mentioned just in above post about urist.
So then I started thinking about pyx. There’s what urist said in his latest post. … but I mean a scum urist could come up with that reasoning… not too hard. BUT… there actually have been things that pyx has done that I’m not too fond of. I think the main thing is giving town crap for doing certain things. Like… acting worried that a lynch will happen if he goes to sleep… because of the smilodon lynch that he tends to bring up.
Also… there were posts at one section of the game where I truly believed like he was trying to cause confusion. I can maybe try to find them… if anyone needs.
I also wasn’t a fan of his sudden turnaround on me. When I was looking for reasons for him to be town, like Josh possibly getting a view… making the Miller claim make sense - he said “see that’s why you’re town”. I think proclaimed that I thought pyx could be town and didnt want to lynch there. Almost right after that, he says he thinks I could be scum.
^this one isn’t a very good reason on my part. Because everyone is paranoid and reads can shift. But… I just thought it was odd at the time. I became peeved.
So there are those things… but there IS the fact that he is saying things like he should be sorted. So… is he really just bluffing and taking a huge chance that we won’t catch his bluff? I dont know. (Also pyx is looking pretty solvey)
So then. I also got to thinking about Andres. And honestly… maybe. He has acted a bit jumpy throughout the game when anyone called him scum. But hes very earnest sounding. Maybe though. I never really finished my iso on him. It will help when hes able to post more
I heartily agree with both of those. Scum most certainly wanted Screen lynched, and especially since he didn’t claim the 2-shot. And Urist seems so absolutely scummy that it becomes a wee difficult to accept that he is. And even if I give MS the insight that maybe the scum kill IS a sleepwalk direct,that still doesn’t explain how our only investigative role would be scum where it surely has to be town and has to be there for both Screen’s confirmed role and my own claim.
Not right then. Maybe later in the game… if he keeps on surviving, it could be argued that something fishy is going on. But not so vehemently when so many town were against it. It would just be asking to get quick lynched next day
@Mantis, I do not in any way get why any townie would be so perplexed at being reevaluated, esp. where we are in this game. Who do YOU think has been the most sure of where to lynch?
And do you not even see how the N! target of _fferyllt casts FOS on the other 2 in Temple chat where he specifically vocalised suspicion of both Nanook and cabd?
VC 4-14
Metal Sonic: 1 (catspurr)
Urist: 1 (Metal Sonic)
Not voting: 5 (Urist, pyx, Andresvmb, Judge Mental, Mantis)
With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.
Deadline: September 15, 2018 4:00 AM
This topic will close automatically 30 minutes after the deadline.
Mod Notes:
Links
Day 1 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 2 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 3 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 4 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
sigh that’s exactly why I said it wasn’t a good reason! But I still thought I would state that it occurred to me as a bit weird. I remember asking judge about it coming out of nowhere. Anyway
Who has been more consistent? I guess urist or andres.
Can you provide some more background for this belief? This is definitely worth exploring.
It’s a sense of the top of my head. Urist is pretty solid on either pyx or cats. With you, I actually wasnt sure of your reads until you posted your longish post a few days ago. Haven’t really seen you in thread jumping votes like ms cats and judge have. They look like they’re agonizing a bit over it. Similar to how I feel
2 Likes
ha ha nfi but it’s a cop role and pyx has claimed miller
the reason for why my reads haven’t changed much since d2 is because I haven’t been reading that closely. The shitty thing about lynching two scum so early is that we now have no associative tells. I have no idea who the scum is, and since everybody is lost at this point, scum can say pretty much whatever they want. It sucks and I’m demoralized and I don’t have the energy to read a 5k post thread. I know I’m just being a whiny potato but I feel like this game has become a bit of a chore at this point. Maybe that’ll change if I am still alive in the next few game days, but really it just feels like there are too many people to look at and every time I think “oh X might be scum” my brain wants to interject with “But they did townie things A, B, C, D!” I have reasons for thinking everyone could be town and I have reasons for thinking everyone is scum and I don’t know how to rank the scummy things vs the townie things to see who has the highest scum:town ratio. Like I have no idea. And pyx playing devil’s advocate with everything I post is certainly not helping either. 
It’s just been my experience that when among players of some renown, the ‘deep wolf’ mafioso is rarely the one who looks most guilty but the one who looks very townish.
yeah the emote is misleading, i’m not mad or anything, more that i’m already doubting everything i say so you echoing my doubts just makes it harder to figure out where to place a vote. :\
That’s sort of where the idea of final voting came to be, on my part. That and i really thought it was MS 
…since has changed.
This innue is helping scum.
Thing is, I believe town is still way ahead.
7 of us alive, best case scenerio we are 6 town to 1 scum.
Worst case 5 town to 2 anti-town.
Either way we are not at lylo.
We can sort pyx or one of us VT and still be ahead tomorrow.
Say we mislynch, then; BC 4 to 1 worst case 3 to 2, so we just have to decide to bite the bullet and lynch.
What about if we do a lynch list each of 3 players we are willing to lynch and then see were they match up?
I guess pyx is in the mix because of the miller/2 shot protect claim.
He is a power role claimant.
It’s just the miller role.
But then is Andre a power Role?
Was Josh a power Role?
Anyway, I think my possible list now has to be:-
Metal, Mantis. Andre and I could go pyx if that is the only agreement.
We keep talking about a town consensus, but we have NOT really tried to reach one.
All we have been doing is saying why it should not be us.
I am happy to be in the lynch candidates.
UNVOTE: METAL SONIC