There’s a good chance he is if we share the same thoughts, especially this early.
I disagree that Judge is likely scum if you are town. I would like to know why Judge thinks the votes on Pyx are random.
Catspurr’s early claim is believable.
Do you doubt his claim or assumed alignment from that claim?
Um? Maybe, I guess I just thought it would be obvious.
Your right, I didn’t think it through, although, town would also be wondering why I am around causing wifom, So maybe better that everyone knows I can certainly be killed.
As to the timing of the reveal, I hate it going down to the wire and then at the last minute someone say, wait, I am the Doc/Investigative/roleblocker.
A few other people have revealed minor powers already, unless it is all a joke?
I don’t know anyone in this game so am finding players totally confusing.
As mentioned I don’t know anyone so have no Meta to work from.
Can see the argument for pyx being scum, they have done no scum hunting, but there are a lot of players who haven’t contributed in any constructive way. <>
The only other player I have a niggle about is screenplay, not because they voted me, this was afterward when they seemed to overreact to the guapos law reference.
chesskid3 seems to be doing a lot of the driving for town, which is fine, town needs go gettum players.
Not sure why they think judge and pyx have to be on opposite sides?
Yeah, it will take a while to get to know each other.
My strategy is always to keep scum guessing. You can always explain a situation if/when town needs to know. There are lots of reasons someone might live through a lynch - Lynchproof, protected, other role powers.
Anyway, not going to offer a lecture. Styles differ, site to site, so whatever you’re used to doing likely works in context.
I would never assume Pyx’ alignment from D1. And will be disappointed if he’s lynched to early. Even if he is scum, best to watch him awhile. IME. 
No idea about the judge/pyx connection. Maybe it is just scummy wifom. Or town prodding.
lol sure thing
chesskid3
dumb or scum
vote chesskid3
because they were?? I found your hedge on catspurr pinged; now your question of me begs the question of what pressure, in your opinion, catspurr was under, per #112 iirc (sorry at work on fone being surreptitious)
where’s this coming from?
Dan sell me a house on the world in which Pyx and Judge are both town please?
Chesskid said one or the other is scum. So that’s where. They didn’t explain really, hence the talk.
Crap. I’m still not managing the quote function well.
Hmm that’s not quite what I said
This is what you said.
Yep that is indeed what I said good job
I said “~A implies B”
You said I said “A or B”
precision matters
Are you saying B doesn’t imply A?
Maybe you could explain what makes you suggest A implies B in the first place, since frankly it appears to have been fabricated from thin air without your offering further explanation.