MHA Mafia Game Thread - Game Over

[orangeandblack5]

@Arete

In a game I played on my homesite all the townies had ‘good guy’ flavors and all the scum had ‘bad guy’ flavors and there weren’t enough unused ‘good guy’ flavors for scum so a mass flavor claim would have broken the game if it had been allowed (obviously it wasn’t, the host just modkilled anyone who flavorclaimed)

That’s a bad way to handle that jeez

[orangeandblack5]

his blood is on your hands

[clonedcheese]

@orangeandblack5 I didn’t think that was an active mechanic lol

Just thought it was a fake one to tell ppl

[Arete]

@darth_tabor

Sorry, what are scum fakeclaims? Like I know what a fakeclaim is, but I thought that was just something the players do, but you’re implying mods are involved in this?

Fakeclaim can mean 2ish things:

• a flavor that you pretend to have (usually one given to you to fakeclaim), like how in PMMM the Magical Girls all had fake Witch flavors
• a fake role that you pretend to have (like a scum member being like ‘oh I’m a Parity Cop’ or whatever)

[JakeTheWolfie]

Roses are Violets
Violets are Roses
You wouldn’t part me
Like the red sea and Moses

[orangeandblack5]

@darth_tabor give me what flavor claim this is

[Arete]

@orangeandblack5

That’s a bad way to handle that jeez

Take it up with Luxy

[orangeandblack5]

Is there any, like, red and blue half-and-half guy

[Arete]

@DoggoPlays

VOTE: firekitten

also okay voting jake if things swing that way

this is also super OMGUSy!! why is everyone in this game just OMGUSing!!

[orangeandblack5]

I’m omgusing

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

@DoggoPlays

like what fucking moonworld did I just walk into

Here.

[Arete]

@DoggoPlays

having a 1000 post game with maybe 50 relevant posts is toxic to everyone involved.

this just in

actually playing the game and trying to solve people’s alignments is toxic

[deadbananas]

@orangeandblack5

Is there any, like, red and blue half-and-half guy

I looked it up and theres a guy that can use fire and ice

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

Doggo got extremely confrontational in that game against Nanook, Chess and me, and he was Scum and we were all Town. You can go check it out.

[darth_tabor]

@Arete

why are we confirming people based on flavor?? given that apparently mass flavor claims don’t break the game scum almost certainly have fake flavor claims because otherwise we could just massclaim and probably win

I’m not saying that it 100% clears them. Regardless of flavor, it’s a bad play to claim this early. However, based on the flavor and the fact that there are clear mechanics that could be associated with Bakugo’s character, I believe this claim to be real.

There is also the perspective that someone would only make a play like this if they had guaranteed security (i.e.e fakeclaim), which I find unlikely but am willing to entertain.

[clonedcheese]

@orangeandblack5

Is there any, like, red and blue half-and-half guy

shoto Todoroki, a fire-and ice guy

[orangeandblack5]

sounds like it

Does he use poetry or some shit

[orangeandblack5]

Does he poem

[Arete]

@Arete

@Arete

I’ve seen it twice but in one instance they were scum and also a miller which feels like kind of a noncentral example

How can a player that is Scum also be a Miller? What is the point?

the set-up of the game was that alignments, roles, and “modifiers” could all roll separately, and one rollable modifier was Miller, so he rolled Mafia for his alignment and miller as a modifier

the set-up also had a modifier cop, who he got to check him and confirm him as miller

if you really want I can try to find the thread? I wasn’t actually in the game but I read through it later

[Firekitten]

@Andresvmb

Here.

I skimmed through a little bit but he actually was being confrontational while actually doing something in that game

Here’s he’s being confrontational without actually, you know, being useful