MHA Mafia Game Thread - Game Over

[Arete]

@Andresvmb

There’s no way this is accurate hahaha

I hate this post

[Arete]

like I don’t even think you’re wrong

but ‘one of your six townreads is probably wrong’ is not a useful thing to say without information about which ones you disagree with/why/etc.

[Arete]

@Firekitten

@Srceenplay

This felt hedgy.
Like they are calling them town but not wanting to call them town. Keeping options open kinda thing.

@Arete

for what it’s worth Marshal is definitely capable of faking confidence as W

going to be honest I think it doesn’t really matter that marshal can fake confidence if he’s not really trying his hardest in this game

it matters when trying to read him on confidence or lack thereof

[Arete]

@Andresvmb

Okay, I think we find Scum in {Arete, Erik, GoalkeeperBoss}. Or maybe not. It’s early still

assuming 4 scum there are better than even odds of finding scum in any arbitrarily chosen set of three people

do you have reasons for picking these three

[Arete]

@Andresvmb

I also disagree with #532 (and also doesn’t help my read). If you had actually read through the site, there’s no way you come out with the conclusion that Srceen placing naked votes with little explanation is all of a sudden an indicator that he’s Scum, and him answering the question about how many Scum is bad because? Srceen’s response in #540 is exactly how I feel haha

I’ve read through games on this site and noticed a general attitude that posting a lot is bad and Screenplay is from this site

I mostly wasn’t paying attention to specific people other than my friends

[Arete]

@GoalkeeperBoss

That’s a bold move hopping in halfway through day 1 and just jumping on the top wagon. I wanna hear more from you
VOTE: Andresvmb

this feels OMGUSy and I’m not really a fan

[Arete]

@deadbananas

To the people voting GKB is it just to try to get him to post more like Jake or do you actually get a scum feel?

@deadbananas

Cause reading through GKB 's posts I dont see anything that jumps as scum to me, but he isnt really being helpful to the town or active either.

this feels really hedgy

VOTE: deadbananas

[deadbananas]

@GoalkeeperBoss

Look at this try hard trying to solve the game

Bad start for GKB since he is responing to a legit question about the game, but it was within approx 30 minutes of the game started so can be taken as a joke.

@GoalkeeperBoss

I’m tryna read the room rn, it’s a good thing I’m illiterate cuz there is nothing to read here

Joking attitude and dismissive of developments in the thread, not sure of this comes from a scum place or a disinterested townie though.

@GoalkeeperBoss

That’s a bold move hopping in halfway through day 1 and just jumping on the top wagon. I wanna hear more from you
VOTE: Andresvmb

This is probable the worst post. GKB wasn’t the top wagon and has less posts than andre, also feels OMGUS af.

[Arete]

Jake feeling really unconcerned about the votes on him is probably a good look for him based on meta

in my experience he gets really aggressive and ?bitter? when people are pushing him as scum and he’s not doing that here at all

[deadbananas]

overall looking back feels more scummy than dismissive so putting GKB as a scumlean, I would like to see him actually contribute to the thread and scum finding.

[deadbananas]

VOTE: Goalkeeperboss

[deadbananas]

how do you feel about him apparently self imposing a Post restriction on himself?

[Arete]

that’s unfortunately NAI for him

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

@Arete

assuming 4 scum there are better than even odds of finding scum in any arbitrarily chosen set of three people

do you have reasons for picking these three

So you’re suggesting that I randomly picked three players because my odds of having at least one of them flip Scum is better than even? That seems like quite the accusation - anything there that makes you think that this is how I would play the game?

I’ve explained my read of you I think in some detail, and GKB has responded horribly to pressure so I don’t think I’m off there. Erik is a gut read, in terms of where they fit in the overall scheme. That one is obviously the one most subject to change.

[clonedcheese]

Alright
Sorry for the delay - parents going full OCD on my room

GKB vote analysis:

Erika: Appears to be RVS, because people were discussing GKB at the time. Only thing going against him was that he “leaked” that his rolecard had more than one color. Following the kinda large loud wagon of Orange + Arete I presume.

Started pressuing GKB for being slow on responding, but hey, the FRC simulator contest (as like half the people in this thread know) is pretty time-consuming.

@ErikaFurudo any changes in opinion since yesterday?

Litten: (I don’t care about your name here I’m just going to refer to you as Litten because it sounds better)

@orangeandblack5

also hi fire vote gkb with me

Only reasoning I see other than the “GKB was slow” argument

Seththeking:

@Seththeking

@GoalkeeperBoss

Sounds about right

Yeah I really don’t like this.
VOTE: GoalkeeperBoss

My votes staying here for now.

what exactly don’t you like about this?

You also say that you “checked” some people throughout your mini-barrage last night - would you like to explain/share your findings?

Side note

@Seththeking

Hey! I’m not no grammar perfectionist!

How did I miss this
Scum confirmed, only scum uses bad grammar

Andresvmb:

@Andresvmb

I think I’ve said quite a bit already to be totally honest, in the sense that either you can ask questions about stuff I have posted or otherwise reasonably make up your mind as to where I stand. I hate your OMGUS vote, and also the fact that you’re painting yourself as the top wagon when in fact… you weren’t. I tied the vote, not piled onto the top wagon (which would have been JaketheWolfie btw).

Yes GKB did a OMGUS ( when someone votes someone because that someone is voting them) but you never explained your own vote. Please, in your own words, describe your thought process in putting pressure on GKB.

deadbananas:

@deadbananas

overall looking back feels more scummy than dismissive so putting GKB as a scumlean

I get that you are suspicious of OMGUS and his lack of contribution; however I’d say both of these are NAI (Not Alignment Indicative). Any other reasons for voting GKB?

Also Elli and other mods idk if it’s just my computer sucking but my computer crashed when I tried to load my post with the 6 custom emojis

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

@Arete

like I don’t even think you’re wrong

but ‘one of your six townreads is probably wrong’ is not a useful thing to say without information about which ones you disagree with/why/etc.

So you think I’m right but hate my post? And I think you already know where I disagree.

[Seththeking (TrueSoulEnergy)]

@GoalkeeperBoss

That’s a bold move hopping in halfway through day 1 and just jumping on the top wagon. I wanna hear more from you
VOTE: Andresvmb

This is a scum claim by GKB.
GKB wasn’t even the top wagon, Jake was.
Andre voted it to make both GKB and Jake at 4 votes.

The GKB slot needs to die today.

[Arete]

@Arete

@Arete

assuming 4 scum there are better than even odds of finding scum in any arbitrarily chosen set of three people

do you have reasons for picking these three

So you’re suggesting that I randomly picked three players because my odds of having at least one of them flip Scum is better than even? That seems like quite the accusation - anything there that makes you think that this is how I would play the game?

…no

I am saying that saying ‘this list of three people has at least one scum’ with almost no explanation is pretty much completely useless even if technically probably true

like this post is the first you’re explaining anything about your read on Eric

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

@clonedcheese

Yes GKB did a OMGUS ( when someone votes someone because that someone is voting them) but you never explained your own vote. Please, in your own words, describe your thought process in putting pressure on GKB.

#689.

[clonedcheese]

@Srceenplay

if he doesn’t have a pr it kinda feels like he is forcibly trying to change his play style. It’s not needed as town.

maybe he’s just trolling? It’s day 1…

@orangeandblack5

This is a bad take lol

explain why lmao