Mafia 451 Draft

Completed Games Completed Onsite
, ,
#2322

You both drafted very differently than I would have.

GG.

#2323

In practice people cry “wifom!” A lot more than decisions are actually made to be wifom.

If you lynch correctly there and then another night goes and doc doesn’t die again… I mean it gets you thinking.

Maybe I undervalue docs but I think the community massively overvalues them

#2324

For the latter point the role combination of having the gov is relevant.

I think you’re making assumptions on how people would think about the implications of things. We’re drafting and assigning for a particular set of players.

And if we’re talking an arbitrary set of players I think the only “real” way to look at how much better a role is by calculating tries/chance to hit/result.

#2325

Is he man or machine

1 Like
#2326

lmao Hannah

#2327

hopefully my next game will be a town game, anyways gg guys

#2328

I think once one doc flips scum you can probably assume the other is scum too, but idk maybe that’s just knowing a little about Elli’s preferences

#2329

playerwise or roles?

#2330

also ggs every1 this was definitely a game

#2331

D1 was fun.

D2 was ok to watch.

The rest happened.

#2332

that’s why i said it was “a game”

1 Like
#2333

You didn’t lose the role draft chess, the only important role you didn’t get was governor (I don’t think the docs were that important without good investigatives).

#2334

I think the dayvig/vengeful roles are strong if scum get them, along with governer

#2335

i wanted both to 100% go to town since higher chance of town shooting town haha

#2336

This relates to math, I trust you here :joy:

#2337

Fair!

Overall was a pretty fun game for my, I dunno, third real “active” game this year? Thanks for letting me play :smile:

#2338

@Ellibereth SC2mafia has a condorcet voting system you may be interested in looking into. It essentially forces you to rank everyone and then takes everyone lists and lynches the most highly suspected overall

1 Like
#2339

Aww, thanks for neighbourising me so early, I liked being able to talk to you! I should have defended you more based on you being so active and solvy in the hood, but not sure it would have helped after I died. Definitely could have tried to convince you more on Andres town based on Srceenplay lynch instead of posting that paranoia read after the DS flip.

@StarV we almost got a good poe at some point

Nuxl never getting lynched despite being a top scumread of like the entire town was pretty educational.

#2340

StarV told me that he reads less than half the posts in any given game and that he just lynches people who he cant read which I think are like two conflicting ideas but anyway him being on literally all of the town lynches is probably because of that. He should take this L whole heartedly I think. Forced the gladiate between two townies d1, then we lynched screen, then he was just throwing his vote onto townies for the rest of the game really.

In other news I want to apologize for my misread on Andres. Your progression from me being town to me being scum just didnt make any sense at all to me and that was the main reason I scum read you.

I also would hope that Nuxl/Action Dan’s inactivity in the ranked game wasnt linked to them rolling scum in this game, and actually would suggest for ranked integrity sake that you limit participation to ranked games only to players who are not currently playing other games. That would have likely solved a number of issues in this one.

Thank you M2H for everything, and happy birthday man. I loved the idea of this game, it just was kinda a shit show player wise which is never your fault. Would have liked some sort of mod enforcement on the #friendly tag, but thats just feedback we dont need to get into this again.

2 Likes
#2341

Happy birthday and thanks @M2H for the game! I really enjoyed it and playing with some new people.

GG scum as well, you let town totally eat themselves alive.

1 Like