The inconsistency with the reply button kind of bothers me. I think it should fill in a quote every time you hit it, or, preferably, none of the time you hit it.
Maybe a separate reply and reply with quote buttons, but that might be crowding.
the intention is that it autogenerates when the post in question is far enough that it helps to see the context of the convo. (i.e. i’m super against quoting the post you literally are just replying to).
I get the intention, I don’t think having the reply with quote functionality is bad, but the inconsistency of sometimes including a quote and sometimes not bothers me.
Eh I feel you - I do think we need to educate people about when and when they shouldn’t be quoting because people weren’t quoting enough when referring to posts that happened a while ago.
I’ll let it go on and see how it is. The inconsistency is intentional in that it reflects the desired behavior. (When the quote appears I feel you should be quoting, when it doesn’t you shouldn’t).