Forging of the Rings - Over!

Completed Games Completed Onsite
, ,
#208

I want to scumread this just for using pl0x

#209

too bad he’s town

#210

I dont think we should ALL reveal our rings, but I have no issue revealing something:

I get to target someone and create a private topic with them for the following day and night.

#211

He doesn’t. But he likes to try. He’s caught me a few times as Scum so I wouldn’t totally dismiss it. He’s much better at telling convincingly when I’m Town. And vice versa actually.

#212

That does at least suggest the confidence reading, @Prophylaxis thoughts?

Oh hey messiah is in this game!

#213

And ActionDan wow

@beeboy I generally feel like the later jumps onto a meme wagon are more likely to be scum.

I don’t think ring powers are tied to alignment, especially considering they can be passed around, so I don’t follow your train of thought on M2H. The idea that he just read the power and missed that it was a ring is way simpler to me. I think you’re less likely scum for it though UNVOTE

There seem to be a bunch of votes on m2h though so maybe there’s something there.

#214

I literally do though, and you know this ffs

#215

I don’t think you can read me as accurately when I’m Scum as you think you can. That’s all. I don’t have you nailed either, and called you my Top TR when you were aligned with StarV in a game I would most like to forget.

#216

I’m not all that upset about my vote actually. #213 seems pretty terrible if you ask me. And I have Dan as probably Town.

#217

Strategically, I don’t think revealing much about what you have or not have makes any sense. But you do you.

#218

This in particular. Expressing interest in the largest wagon without much in the form of a rationale seems suspicious to me.

#219

I think beeboy’s reasons don’t make sense and I don’t see much reason to vote there myself, but if AD, Nanook and chess have reasons then of course that’s interesting. Especially given AD explicitly disagreed with bee’s analysis.

#220

You didn’t call the wagon interesting though. You said “there’s something there”. Which implies that M2H is Scum. Now you seem to be backtracking. So which is it?

Yeah, I would take a guess that AD, Chess, and Nanook are not all Scum. So, the odds that at least two of those guys have caught Scum is decent enough that it merits attention. I just thought that the way you are approaching the situation is off.

#221

I used the word interest because you did. Maybe something there, interesting, it’s the same thing.

I’m not sure what you mean by backtracking. I hold the same position I did half an hour ago.

  • beeboy’s analysis doesn’t make sense to me.
  • But there’s three other players (who I think probably have better reads than me) on the wagon, so maybe there’s something there.
  • I don’t feel strongly enough about this to vote there over my personal lack of scumread, so I won’t.
#222

I dont think key vote is very good andres

#223

No one needs to worry about sorting andres. I’ll do that for everyone later.

#224

I’ve read the thread but don’t understand the questioning going on.

Someone who is apart of it want to feel me in from their perspective

#225

Who’s reads are you putting above your own?

#226

I’ll hammer it

#227

I think the biggest thing this means is that we can trust Nanook to give an accurate read on Andres as the game goes on

Who is Messiah?