Eyes Mafia - Day (Game Over!)

Completed Games Completed Onsite
#121

I resign

gg

VOTE: josh

#122

Lol nook, the only reason I am suspicious is because I tracked you visiting the dead guy last night :joy:

The only other explanation really was watcher, which is why I wanted you to claim.

#123

I figured as much! :smiley:

#124

Did scum just surrender? That makes it even easier for us.

VOTE: Josh

#125

I mean, the game was already. Either we lynch Josh today and the game is over, or I get lynched today and flip town, then Josh is lynched. Basically impossible for scum to win barring people just forgetting to vote.

#126

Yep. This is why I usually think investigative roles are OP.

In other news that’s the easiest win I’ve ever had.

#127

Elli was also just a really obvious kill.

#128

i had to hope the watcher was retarded or elli (not mutually exclusive), i wasn’t gonna win with a tracker getting innos and a watcher and an elli

#129

To be fair, if me and shadow’s roles had been swapped, there’s a decent chance she wouldn’t have watched Elli since she’s not familiar with his play.

#130

VC 2-2 Final

Josh: 4 (Nanook, Nix, Josh, shadow)

Not Voting: 2 (NotMafia)

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch

Deadline: July 24, 2018 6:00 AM (Europe: Paris), July 23, 2018 9:00 PM (America: Los Angeles)

Topic will auto-lock 30 minutes after deadline.

Links
Day 1 Start: Eyes Mafia - Day 1
Day 2 Start: Eyes Mafia - Day 1

Mod Notes:

A Lynch Has Been Achieved!

#131
#132

Josh was a Mafia Goon

Town Wins!
#133

Topic reopened! PTS and stuff to come shortly!

#134
#135

lolrip

#136

First, I want to apologize to the players. When I picked two setups to choose from, I wanted the choices to be appealing to players in different ways, but I think having a somewhat townsided game among the picks means that most players will logically pick that setup because it improves the odds of winning, given the odds of drawing town. I thought this was somewhat ameliorated by playerlist size, but it’s not enough.

As this game unfolded, it quickly became a perfect storm of everything possible going wrong for the scum team.

#137

Thanks for hosting fferyllt! And good game everyone.

Don’t worry about the balance, next time you’ll know that maybe this one is a bit townsided.

#138

Roles
Josh - Mafia Goon
sheepsaysmeep - Mafia Rolecop
Shadow - Town Tracker
Nix - Town Vanilla
Ellibereth - Town Vanilla
NotMafia - Town Vanilla
Nanook - Town Watcher

Player/Night Action Night 1
Josh - Mafia Goon - kill Kill Ellibereth - succeeds
sheepsaysmeep - Mafia Roleblocker ded
Shadow - Town Tracker Track Nanook - succeeds
Nanook - Town Watcher Watch Ellibereth - succeeds

Dead Thread: Eyes Closed - Dead Thread
Mafia Thread: Eyes Mafia PT

#139

Hard to really judge the balance from this run I think, cause just about everything that could go wrong for the scum did…and I’m not sure what else they could’ve done. Like, sure, they could’ve not killed Elli…but Elli was a good kill not knowing who the watcher or tracker were, and a 2/5 chance to kill the watcher or tracker, so I can’t come down too hard on them for that. They just got really, really unlucky this time around.

#140

Thanks for the kind words! I think I’ll go back to my roots and do some flavoricious closed setups for a few games.