This is around where I see the game state at the moment. Im thinking with 12 players, 2-3 wolves max but the POE needs to be whittled down a bit to make associative reads. Like if one of those other two flips red I wouldnt necessarily place you as scum with them both if that makes sense?
Town:
skitter30
Andres
catspurr
Srceenplay
Nanook
Urist
Absolute Null:
ActionDan
Riley Cake
POE:
Erika Furudo
Neymar
Mantis
And I would not be super surprised if im being fooled in the town play part of it since Im new to all of these peoples style of play
Donāt really have much useful to add. Feeling a bit lost this game, I think most of this roster is pretty tough for me to read based on playstyle. I do think Erika is playing to their town meta that Iāve seen, for whatever thatās worth.
Probably gonna get a vote down tomorrow, feels weird not having one down yet, but it also feels pretty early to vote a lurker or POE read.
I think Mantisā flip will give me a solid baseline on shaking out the gamestate. Itās day one, I wouldnt expect to have the whole game figured out, but my POE is who I would feel comfortable voting on Day 1 with what we know so far.
I keep coming back to your statement of calling Nanook town, right from the start. I feel like you wouldnāt do that as scum because that would be something Nanook would jump all over. So thatās a big factor.
What is specifically weird though? The change in thought that DS was scum? The fact that I voted him in the first place? The whole thing was blown out of proportion and obviously I didnt take his claim at face value, thatās idiotic. But it was something to push on at the time, and I mean, I think that should have been obvious. Skitter making a big deal out of it was fine at first, but got to be scummy after awhile. Then as she spoke more and sort of made her own defense in the way that as scum, she would be more careful and probably wouldnāt harp on something like this, I got to possibly believing her. As of now, Iāve reread and Iām a bit null on her, I think she could go either way.
And just to say one last thing, the real time posting and reaction to Erika, on DSās part came across as genuine. Thatās it. Sometimes all it will take, for me, is picking up 1 thing that looks like a blatant town tell with ppl. That said, Iām not going to put him as for sure townā¦ but more of a lean.
Just explaining because I dont really see whatās odd.
I have no clue where to vote atm. Kind of leaning Riley because of poe and feel like Iāve seen townish tells more so from others.
Iām interested in figuring out catsās alignment, Iām not really sure and want to see more
Iām Good.
Iām Not an Ebil Cat this game.
And I am happy having you pegged as town this early in the game because sometimes I find you hard to read.
I can see what you mean that Skitters seems to have been over the top with you, although I can also see you sharp U Turn must be funny to people who donāt know your play.
Ya heheā¦ I was a bit relieved to see that you had the right read on me. Of course could be scum knowing but weāll see. I think this pretty much always happens day 1 for me.
Iām not a fan of Screenplayās vote really. Actually @DS I wanted to ask you why you had him as townish.
Off the bat, I start of just took him to be town. I think he made a decent point w skitters tbh. About plunking a vote down after DS stated his suspicion. It was a valid point.
Iāve asked him about the meta thing with her to see if it would make him reconsider.
What are your thoughts on skitter?
Do you think sheād play scum differently in this game than how she played in ds9?
I only playered a very short time with Skitter as a scum buddy.
It may have only been a game day or two and then she had to ask for a replacement.
So I donāt really know her meta.
Someone, maybe Andre? mentioned she seems more relaxed less careful and that has me giving her a slight town lean at this time, but it is with reservations.
I donāt personally understand why he would make the play of faking a cop check as scum? Whats the purpose there other than a quick day one lynch which would heap tons of suss on him day 2 if his check wasnt correct?
The thing is that, he is now known to do that as town.
So?
He is probably clever enough to do it every game regardless of his alignment.
So I donāt see him doing that as indicative of him being town or scum.
but weāll see. I think this pretty much always happens day 1 for me.
was thinking the same