Or you guys can make a decent case on me
Ok, Ill make a case in few hours (i will start 10 mins later but it will probably take few hours)
DOnt hammer me , Im finally on computer
Christ almighty, how can anyone NOT see that this is scum flailing? Like, I’m genuinely confused how this is fooling anyone, lol
Zzzz
So when gtacc flips green should we lynch you or your buddy ds first? I’ll let you pick!
Welcome to the case on why I should not get lynched and you should lynch DS instead of me!
First of all, I am finally on computer and get to speak. I’ll cover everything. Feel free to ask questions.
I am town and can’t post this much as a scum.
Check all of my games and see it yourself, let me show you my latest scum game:
http://www.blankmediagames.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?f=17&t=91272
In this game, I won because town was not really good. You can see me giving some scumreads at the beginning but being inactive anyways. You can check the neighborhoods, I was kinda active there but did not really try to gamesolve, I usually asked other’s opinions to pocket them. I only had 74 posts, which is not really much for a game that lasted 4 RL days each day and ended at D4.
The town was really inactive tho but anyways, let’s get to the other game.
I had 93 posts, and it’s a game on MU. I beg for towncred (derped few times, gave immediate iso, etc.)
Let’s come to town games
Look, I have 158 posts in this one (and I was lynched at some point purely because scum lied and everyone believed them, and for fake mechanics)
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=83&t=76947
I had 47 posts (second most amount of posts) and got lynched when I was right, I have no idea why I got lynched but these are my 2 latest town games.
I mean, you could say I have too many posts because I flailed but if you check it, I don’t flail. (check MU game)
DS is one of the best scum players in the world.
I don’t really know how ranky the MU championship is, but he got 3rd as a scum (originally he had to be 1st but…)
This does not define that he must be scum in this game because I’m getting lynched, bu i think it is worth to mention.
If someone wants, you can read this game
OK, I told I’m gonna do my best but I’m not gonna read all of it lol I have a life (?)
Summary
Why DS is scum in this game
He claimed mafia.
That’s all, folks!
JK JK, he did it because he wanted early towncred for reaction testing.
This is a defensive post, Mantis just pointed out the early scummy thing and then everyone said Mantis is scum for that.
If you were not being serious in your first post, why are you taking Mantis’ vote that serious?
Sowing the towncred from the first post.
Yeah you’ll gonna remember lynching outside of Mantis the whole game
“I’m gonna read anyone that got into this conversation” is not a good mindset, it just points to you being town since you are the one who started it. Trying to get towncred.
He then turns back to Mantis scumread by calling it opportunistic (I thought you said, joining the discussion was good?) which lasted for too long. This is kind of an OMGUS and opportunistic push because Skitter pointed that out already.
I have no idea why he says this, what is the point of outing a green check anyways?
Meh, he did not know it was meta to RVS but why a post like this, like speaking like an another character, seems scummy to you?
Having never played forum mafia with any of these players before I’m trying to differentiate them all in my mind before throwing a vote around
Why are you being cautious about your vote while you already claimed scum in your first post? I thought you liked reactions.
Not a fan of Erika because im not seeing any real logic to her reads or you since youre parking a vote on me, but those could both be seen as omgus reasonings
Little iffy on Nanook’s gif thing, maybe could be an attempt at pocketing but not sure yet, I think given time I can read him properly.
Your vote on me is really bad btw
OMGUS reasons, also saying Nanook tried to pocket DS is pretty off.
The fact that so many people have thoughts on Neymar when they haven’t even posted yet to my knowledge is something that makes me unlikely to vote there today
Trying to distract attention from AFK partner.
Vote just doesnt make sense in any logical way. Also, you said that you liked it, so are you backtracking now or what?
Why do you care so much about 1 vote? Why is it disturbing you?
Are you trying to get ready to deathtunnel?
I’m just asking you a question because you gave them possible scum equity and then voted a no poster
VOTE: Erika Furudo
WK’ing Neymar, he think reaction testing is good, then votes Erika when they could get reactions from Neymar for that vote?
DS is town.
This is a pretty bad use of announcer if you are town, why are you trying to make people think you are town instead of posting reads or such useful uses of announcer?
Wolves wanna look town more than town instead of gamesolving, it is a fact.
There’s a town announcer idiots.
<em>Sincerely,
Not the Mod</em>
Trying to create the sense of announcer being town, if you were town, putting town near your name probably would not came to your mind.
Why are you trying to out the town announcer? That’s super anti-town imo
Why do you think announcer is a super important town role, when you used it like 4 times for questionable uses?
So you really think that scum claimed mafia in their first post and then their scum partner voted the person that voted them?
Where’s the logic there for a skitter/DS wolf team? I don’t see it
Have you even seen a power wolf? I mean, Mantis was most likely wrong but It’s still opportunistic
I was making a play on words.
Lolcatting is when scum is caught and doesn’t know what to post so they don’t spew their scummates so they just post cat pictures and memes to finish the phase.
When you start making posts like “mmhmm” and “lol” instead of trying to solve the game, it is reminiscent of lolcatting
Mmhmm was not catting, it points out to the contradiction of DS’s reads, DS just used those 2 posts opportunistically.
Erika with another scummy post lmfao
That post is scummy for… what?
This conversation is weird
I think there’s scum here
Both were your scumreads, you can say that again.
That read is so bad I don’t even think urist is scum pushing me but just like really bad at mafia
Are you calling everyone scum/bad that calls you scum?
To me it seemed like an attempt to switch the conversation away from Mantis’ sketchy progressionless reads
Yeah that assumes Erika and Mantis are both scum
Both Cats/Andres both seem relatively townie to me off of their last series of posts each
Ok, Andres had a wall but what about cat? Because they said Andres is good as scum? Then you gotta conftown me for saying you are a really good scum lmfao
This is around where I see the game state at the moment. Im thinking with 12 players, 2-3 wolves max but the POE needs to be whittled down a bit to make associative reads. Like if one of those other two flips red I wouldnt necessarily place you as scum with them both if that makes sense?
Town:
skitter30
Andres
catspurr
Srceenplay
Nanook
Urist
Absolute Null:
ActionDan
Riley Cake
POE:
Erika Furudo
Neymar
Mantis
And I would not be super surprised if im being fooled in the town play part of it since Im new to all of these peoples style of play
I thought Neymar was town because they were talked about too much? Do you think you buddied their slot too much? You literally said nothing about neymar before this post.
Also how do you associate Neymar with Erika at this point?
I actually really like this post from you. Reads as frustrated town.
So you are backtracking and read Mantis as frustrated town? You read Mantis’ sub out scummy when Mantis’ top metareader Urist was calling it town lmao
My switch from Erika to Mantis had a lot to due with Mantis’ horrible push on me and the fact that she had literally been voting me since my first post in the game, which you are clearly ignoring as like a solid motivation for grabbing someone’s attention on day one, and if you actually read what it is I posted you would see that it’s really the lack of reads progression that I find super scummy about Mantis.
For Neymar, I didn’t like his pop in and how he entered the game. Would I vote there today? Likely not, because I got a weird feeling about how much he was mentioned at the beginning of the day before he showed up, though that doesn’t mean he isn’t in the POE simply for lack of participation which, often enough, is a scum tell for some players.
You also have been voting me since my first post, you never evaluated me ever. Also distancing with Neymar but trying to get them not lyched.
OK guys, at this point I am really tired and gonna analyze less, like it was just 1/9 of the game. But you get the idea, DS’s goal is trying to get my slot lynched (also erika at that point) and trying to protect neymar. He does not likes vote on himself, def seems like a scum mindset.
Alright so I think I’m going to reveal something about my role because thinking about it in relation to Dans really weird totally not masons claim and having read the history of the characters he mentioned it seems a bit intriguing to me when I think about a portion of my role which is a one shot and allows me to pick three players to disallow protection on for two night phases. Now I always thought that was a weird one shot for a townie to have, but if there is some sort of tandem SK duo with protection capabilities it makes a bit more sense for me to have this nullification power.
How the f did you think mason claims are serial killers that can protect each other?? And why would you claim that:
and I 100% would not claim that shit on day one if I was scum
To make this argument of course.
What’s the Case on nanook? I’d rather vote mantis
Asking what is the case on someone is an ez scum tell. Check my mafia 451 game I linked for that. Also check Neighborhood game and check mafiascum game. Scum asked about the wagon in all of that.
However, this could be for distracting the wagon instead of joining it, idk.
If no ones on mantis with me I may move to neymar
“If no ones on my lynch target with me, I might bus for distance because Neymar and Nanook are only choices who are my scumfriends and neymar is less active.”
I almost would want to have Nanook prove his role though.
“I dont like the eod with 2 of my partners.”
Hmmm… wonder if my role would stop Clems
Scumslip
Why the f would you wonder that??? Do you want people to die at night??
So, the question is now:
Who do I use my one shot power on? Tonight would be a perfect time to try it and we can try and direct the mafia shot onto one of them assuming they believe Nanooks claim
Why do you want a town dead so much? Scum can just nokill if you disabled them
OK I had to go for now but this is everything DS posted scummy at d1 and analyze of it, Ill analyze next parts if I dont get hammered soon and make a case on myself that why Im town.
Check summary for most of it, its kinda hidden
I believe that scum does not have a daychat
UNVOTE: Gtacc
I was actually going to ISO DS and Gtacc to try and make up my mind, but it looks like Gtacc has done a lot of that work already. My Mason Partner knows how I feel about all this - mechanically I think we’d be making a mistake by lynching Gtacc, but again I’m not splitting my vote with him.
Btw, @Urist why are you asking Skitters to use the JK on you and Srceenplay? That’s totally worthless. If only one of you is Scum, then what? And does anybody think that’s not possible?
@Skitter30, you must know that if we’re the Scum Team, we have lost the game already. So do not waste your time JK’ing the both of us and just use it on AD. AD already explained why it will not result in both of our deaths, unless something else happens. But again, if we’re not going to follow logic, then sure JK us both and be done with it. We’ve already asked you not to do that, but I can’t force your hand.
If I was scum I could kill any of them because I have protection nullifier
Definitely not scum, definitely the doc
Christ almighty, how can anyone NOT see that this is scum flailing? Like, I’m genuinely confused how this is fooling anyone, lol
Seriously. Their eod with the hunter lie and then all of this is just blatantly obvious
Hey, stop flattering me.
I’m also one of the best town players in the world btw.
Think about this: Gtacc was at L-1 for hours last night. If they were town, why wouldn’t scum just hammer?
Vote Count 3.8
RedFlavor (4): Andres, Nanook, DS, catspurr
DS (1): RedFlavorNot Voting (5): skitter30, ActionDan, Mylo, Urist, Screenplay
Deadline: November 6, 2018 3:00 AM
With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
After this vote count, Gtacc voted themself putting them at L-1, so unless you think the entire scum team is within Andres, Nanook, and Catspurr, then scum has a chance to hammer a town!gtacc
Since that didn’t happen, mechanically Gtacc is scum. It’s obvious.
Also, what townie self votes like that in a 1v1 situation? That’s super suss in and of itself.
1)Scum can choose to not hammer me but this is not the case cuz
2)Scum is between you, cats and nanook. It is you and nanook
Also because of few things about assosiations, I thought you were town but then I was like nah, DS is still mafia
If it’s me and Nanook why even bring up Cats name?
I’m 100% the doc, and you know this.
Because he was also voting me and he is not mason