holy shit. I’ve never read 1,000+ posts, to jump into a game, before…
heh. I don’t get why the lynch of this slot has become a consuming thing for day 1. Could be that at least one scum is happily keeping this at the forefront of discussion. Just to be clear, I’ve managed to read through just the once and will not be bothered re-reading AD’s posts nor answering questions you might’ve been wanting them to answer. If you guys do decide to lynch this slot, then I’ll be annoyed about the hours I’ll never get back.
I’ve not made notes, so I’ll just run through what thoughts I’m having about various players, taking the list from ffery’s latest VC. Speaking of, I’m just going to unvote AD’s vote so that the vote will be mine even if I do go with cats. UNVOTE: cats
catspurr: 2 meh. They are going back to the “nanook pisses me off so I’m not going to vote there but I could well vote there” too often. Refer below for additional scum points. Could vote here
Nanook: 2 slight town lean. In the earlier part of the game I found myself agreeing with them during their battle with screenplay’s as-it-turns-out fake claim and ExcuseGate. I started to be less keen with their posts from the point of debating Mantis on…dunno, insubstantial stuff that I can’t bring to mind right now.
Srceenplay: 1 don’t know: must be a cultural thing because I found their fake claim particularly pointless and seemed to me to serve the sole purpose of riling Nanook. Um, congrats, I guess? The only good thing that I got from that saga was that cats was goaded easily into a vote on them prior to it being established the clear was fake, which is scum points for cats, null for them.
Andresvmb: 1 I flip-flop on my read here. On the one hand I see - way wordy but still - scum hunting effort. OTOH the willingness to dive into tangential stuff / minutiae brings the thought “scum filler” to mind. The lurker argument is very tedious and I wonder if their intensity is genuine
_fferyllt: 1 yeah I don’t see anything towny here. The stance on smilodon seems very opportunistic. Could def vote here
smilodon as a sub-in I have loads of compassion for them. Neutral on them at the moment. AFKDG (sorry can’t recall the initials) was a mystery.
Mantis neutral. I know their game quite well and wishy-washy is definitely part of that. Strong reaction to Josh surprised me.
Urist my strongest town read. I vaguely recall they did the dumb first post but once they got serious I liked their posts
MS big meh. I expect them to vote me because they don’t like my avatar – as they have done in previous games with me – and I’ve not seen anything of substance from them. Happy to vote here
CABD honestly, happy they replaced skitter only for the fact that I found skitters’ WoTs tiresome, this is my bad. I found skitter towny so happy to keep that read for now.
parsec happy to accept the miller claim and in that light their posts sync as towny.
Josh no idea. They are iirc the only player happy to vote MS and this is towny because MS is and should be an easy target. I wonder if there is history with urist to explain the antagonism between them. Is the only player wanting to vote urist iirc and staying on urist could be scum inertia.