Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

[catspurr]

Andre / 3
Urist / 3
Cats / 2
Metal / 1
Mantis / 1
Pyx / 1

Judge Mental /0

[Mantis]

it’s pretty funny how it was Judge that wanted out of this game, the most, out of anyone. And here she sits with 0 votes on her

[Mantis]

what if she’s the scum ???

[catspurr]

CATSPURR
Andre
Metal

METAL SONIC
Urist
Andre

ANDRES
Urist
Mantis

MANTIS.
Andre
Pyx

Alright, I am making it top two picks.

URIST @Urist
Catspurr
?

PYX
Urist
Catspurr

JUDGE @Mental
?
?

[MetalSonic]

then I will never trust that avatar again

[Mantis]

[catspurr]

I keep thinking that.
What If?

But, like her suggestion of a traitor I don’t think we realy want to worry about that today.

[Mantis]

no let’s not worry about that… agreed but for real… She is town. If she’s scum… she can win it. Agreed?

[catspurr]

For today.
If we get to lylo maybe not.
But who so ever is scum can get a medal at least, no matter whom it is.!

[Mantis]

I full heartedly agree with this

[Mantis]

I don’t think Urist will be back. He went and made the baby calm somehow… so he is shackled, whilst I am free. But… it would have been better still, if he could post more.

[Mantis]

I still really like that you have made it so that we can all see who we want to lynch (top 2). It’s helpful.

I still don’t really get what your reasonings are for wanting to lynch me @Andresvmb

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

VC 4-16

catspurr: 1 (Urist
Urist: 1 (Metal Sonic)

Not voting: 5 (pyx, Andresvmb, Judge Mental, Mantis, catspurr)

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline: September 15, 2018 4:00 AM

This topic will close automatically 30 minutes after the deadline.

Mod Notes:

Links
Day 1 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 2 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 3 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 4 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

[catspurr]

As everyone say Mantis, any 7 of us could be scum.
You are not longer in my pick cause you were number three.

Andre because his role with the orb could fit in with scum, the sleepwalking being a scum board power. He could have needed to steal and orb to be a part of the neighbourhood town board.
Bit of a stretch maybe, but so is everyone else.
As Andre says, we all need to reassess how assumptions.

And talking of reassessing our assumptions I have decide that the sleepwalking for metal does not have to be alignment indicative and that CABD could have picked on scum buddy Metal without giving him a choice or even discussing it with him.

If it was Not discussed first, Metals reactions to CABD make sense.

[Mantis]

As everyone say Mantis, any 7 of us could be scum.
You are not longer in my pick cause you were number three.

Andre because his role with the orb could fit in with scum, the sleepwalking being a scum board power. He could have needed to steal and orb to be a part of the neighbourhood town board.
Bit of a stretch maybe, but so is everyone else.
As Andre says, we all need to reassess how assumptions.

And talking of reassessing our assumptions I have decide that the sleepwalking for metal does not have to be alignment indicative and that CABD could have picked on scum buddy Metal without giving him a choice or even discussing it with him.

If it was Not discussed first, Metals reactions to CABD make sense.

I continue to agree with you. This is where I was at when I was final voting Metal!!! I thought that there might have been an attempt at distancing, on cabd’s part. And then utter confusion on MS’s part.

Though, I have since changed my mind on Metal.

I am riding with the idea on who I think looks to be in agony. And who is REALLY trying to figure it out. MS, doesn’t quite write lengthy posts on trying to sus. But he did say that he is keeping up with the thread, and he kind of votes as the tides change. One could say that this could be scum. But, it looks to me to be town confusion. …I think???

He’s not sitting back and trying to see where the votes change to, and following where he thinks the votes will move to. He is making votes and essentially, putting out himself out there.

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

See #2371, #2901, #4293 for some examples. Those concerns remain, in part.

I am wondering if Andres, instead of pushing too hard on anyone (like he did in flappers - I looked at that game last week or so, and he pushed quite hard on others) - is instead taking more of a back seat and waiting for town to eat each other alive. I know he is busy with real life though. But, there is that sense that that could be what’s happening. As said before, there are a lot of players that look like we are agonizing over the game.

I am not waiting for Town to eat each other alive. I have been busy.

I am having really strong second thoughts about my opinion of Urist (Pyx I believe made the comment about how the player that looks the Towniest is usually not, which I can see), and I am coming around to the possibility that Cats might be the Scum. I was re-reading some earlier posts, and it certainly seems possible. Ugh, I need to find the time to read through D3 again, and narrow down what I want to do.

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

And talking of reassessing our assumptions I have decide that the sleepwalking for metal does not have to be alignment indicative and that CABD could have picked on scum buddy Metal without giving him a choice or even discussing it with him.

And if you are interested in why, it is stuff like this - the likelihood that the Scum would not discuss how they were going to use a PR, with MS then surprised that he was targeted with such a role, though possible, is ridiculous. That sounds like intentionally playing against your win condition. Why would you do that? And why would such a possibility, given how unlikely it is, be used as the reason that MS is now back in Cats’ lynch pool? Also, if there’s 3 Scum, and Nanook was just vigged, and one of the last 2 is being suspected, would you single out your last remaining Scum buddy so obviously?

[Mantis]

^So Andres, you are saying you don’t think it’s MS, right?

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

I don’t know if it’s MS. Maybe not? What I did not like about Cats’ post is the rationale for changing his view of MS. It seemed… silly.

[catspurr]

As silly as Metals rebuks as to why we should not lynch them?
Can you point me to a Metal rational argument?
This is why I have changed my mind and then I have rationalised it by saying his behaviour makes sense if he was dumped in the shit.

Of the 7 of us they are the one who has made least sense the whole game.
“I have an Awesome Power”
“I don’t think you should lynch srceen but he shouldn’t protect me”

Actually, that does make sense if he was trying to draw the night kill.:shrug:
But after that did not work and there was no night kill, they should have come clean and explained that russ.

Judge asked me who was weird enough to be scum this game.(meaning their play)
And I thought, well Yes, Metal does fit the bill.