Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

VC 4-12


Metal Sonic: 1 (Mantis)
Andressvmb: 1 (Metal Sonic)

Not voting: 5 (Urist, pyx, Andresvmb, Judge Mental, catspurr)

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline: September 15, 2018 4:00 AM

This topic will close automatically 30 minutes after the deadline.

Mod Notes:

  • :slight_smile:

Links
Day 1 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 2 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 3 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 4 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

See, as much as I would love to commit mafia seppuku for the dishonours Iā€™ve inflicted upon this town, self-voting would just add another dishonour to the list. So, you know, Iā€™m kinda stuck there.

The rest of your post doesnā€™t really address my concern, which is fair because I wasnā€™t clear. The problem for me is that cats went from voting nolynch to voting for smilodon, supposedly to avoid a nolynch. His vote on smilodon makes his vote for nolynch look insincere, especially when it was scum getting lynched.

@Urist are you okay with pyx now ?

I could vote metal now.
It is possible that the sleepwalker message was already known to scum so that Metal decided to fake the message the first two nights and then send it to Mantis N3 to get it Credited.
It is possible that CABD and Metal decided Metal should be the fake tracker ā€œTargetā€, that way they know What the target did, maybe Metal did kill _fferyllt.
Most of all Metal has not done anything town.
If you take out the sleepwalking they have only.

Fake claimed a power.
Not put forward any rational argument to save sreen.
And not put forward any rational argument why they arenā€™t scum.
When under pressure, all they do is whine, apeal to emotions and be silly

My argument for Metal being town has been the CABD but if scum were given a choice to send a meesage to a town player each night. You sleepwalked, you have no idea what you did.
That the message was to confus a tracker/cop, as in, if a cop tracked metal to _fferyllt, then metal could say, I must have been possessed, I have a PM from the GM to prove it.

So maybe the sleepwalking is a way to cover up the scum who did the kill.
And they want ā€¦I donā€™t know.

I am agreeing with pyx that, the two likelest suspects are Metal and Urist.
Everyone else just seems Town.

I am sorry metal, but I think we have to sort you.

VOTE: METAL SONIC

could you pls hold a semblance of consistency with your reads?

I get your point Buddy, but, obviously no one is sure of who is scum.
There is no consense on who is scum.
And we have people constantly arguing for who is or is not scum.
YOU are waffling in the wind giving us nothing but your ā€œIā€™ll Lynch Any Bastard to Get Out of Hereā€
AND for some reason we are all seeing that as towny.

(goes looking for icon of blowing hair out of eyes.)

that is bullshit misrepping. I am NOT waffling in the wind. I want you or pyx lynched and will vote either of you in a heartbeat.

the ā€œwe are allā€ is clearly not true because it does not include you in there, which is why I am asking you to at least show a semblance of consistency there.

seriously, if you are town this game itā€™s a game Iā€™ve never seen the likes of from you

Then vote me and put us both out of our misery.:ohyes:

From what some are saying I think you would have a good chance of lynching me.

When you keep saying you want to lynch someone and do nothing about it, Is that NOT Waffling?

Lynch me and I can sing Bohemian Rhapsady as my Swan Song for Mantis!

(thatā€™s not spelt right, I canā€™t be bothered to look it up)

By the By buddy who was it who Final Voted Metal when she keeps saying she want to lynch Cat Or Pyx, Miss consistency? Yes?

No. What I keep saying is that I think you are scummy. I have been utterly unwavering on that.

I think pyx is scummy and I also think his slot needs sorting.

Am happy for either of you to be lynched. Please quote me where Iā€™ve said otherwise or stop misrepping me

heh find a post saying otherwise or please do quieten down with this blatant misrepping, kind sir

but thanks for drawing me back front and centre, when Iā€™ve said my piece (what you are misrepping) and am sitting back out of sheer exhaustion

!!

fake ETA

Well, whatever, I am trying out all sorts of different ideas to see what fits and try to figure out who is scum.

I am agreeing very much with pyx, proabably because he is town reading me.
But he is right that the two who look worst in the game are Urist and Metal.
I think I would add Mantis to that, simply because she was pushing as hard for a town doctor lynch.

But I had cleared Metal simply because of the CABD/METAL interaction, THAT has been the only reason why I have cleared Metal and I have been Consistent with that point of view.

I am now wondering at this stage whether they decided that it was safest for CABD to False Claim Tracker on Metal incase there were other investigative roles. I mean Tracker as a False claim in this game was fairly Ballsy. So maybe they felt they were covering their butts by claiming it against a fellow scum?

LOL you and Judge.

Iā€™m just gonna say Iā€™m stumpped too, and thatā€™s after looking again at cats and Mantis.

See, we know distancing was a prime thing among Nanook and cabd. But going into D2 and for certain D3 it was pretty clear that had not worked to that point, so would it still be a thing?

Certainly cats, followed a bit by Mantis got distanced D1 from who we now know was mafia. MS clearly was distanced D2 with the cabd claim.

So IF we concentrate on who mafia tried to distance themselves from, cats and MS are hard pressed by known mafia, with the Nanook argument with Mantis maybe looking the most staged. But then, in terms of trying to game-solve Mantis comes out as most earnest, followed closely by cats, with MS falling far short, imo. Judge, Urist, and MS seem most willing to lynch cats; while Iā€™m still agreeing with cats on maybe sorting MS or Urist today.

MS and Urist have appealed strongly toward an emotional response, followed byā€¦ others. And most of the dead players have said to lynch Urist, who actually agreed prior that we should were he wrong, which he often has been. Though, OK, he didnā€™t exactly scream to lynch Screen like a certain someone.

And then IF weā€™re going to lynch me it most certainly needs to be no later than today. I would say, hey, letā€™s agree to lynch so-and-so today and if wrong, the other one tomorrow; but that almost never works. So maybe itā€™s who we want as possibly the final 3 (if itā€™s 1 scummie left)?

I really really donā€™t like how MS has manipulated us, but the power of pure puuuuuurrrr has infected me a wee bit.

I think Iā€™m willing to go,
1)Urist
2)MS

or
1)pyx
2)Urist

or, if the consensus everywhere else is to lynch cats, Iā€™ll vote there or at least let that happen.

Again, if we canā€™t get at least 5 or 6 to agree, then we lynch me and let scum narrow the field for whoā€™s left.

I wonā€™t deny that part of it for me too is that I want to go to bed NOW, and I fully realise this thing may likely happen while Iā€™m asleep again.

Iā€™d rather lynch urist than lynch me. Personally.