Urist, I am arguing why your Claim Makes Sense.
If you are our only investigative role, you must be able to ‘see’ all these perbutations going on around you.
If you had ‘viewed’ the doctor, you must have got a town result.
If you ‘viewed’ the miller, you must have got a not town result.
Look I have played in so many Fferyllt games that I know it will all fit together somehow.
AND that most of the claims will be useful meaningful roles. NOT throw away roles that mean nothing.
The spanner in the works is working out which ones are the fake claims for scum.
No, it will not turn out that way. My role and character fit perfectly together as is. Elim Garak fits as both Miller and Bodyguard, much as Worf did as Vig.
Like I said, it’s early in the day yet. I want to review as see which case makes the most sense.
You want the reads list I started today with? Here you go:
T – smilodon AKFD
M – Nanook
T - _fferyllt
M - skitter30 cabd
T - pyx parsec
T - Mantis
T - Judge Mental ActionDan
T - Metal Sonic
T – Catspurr
T? – Andresvmb
I or T^- Josh
? - Urist
? - srceenplay
They are scum who fake claimed yesterday?
At the same time their scum buddy was fake claiming tracker?
They then held off, did NOT put in a Night Kill to Prove they are the town doctor?
I keep coming back to:-
How did they Know there was NO town doctor?
You haven’t counter claimed doctor. Bodyguard is a very different role to doctor.
If you or I were scum pyx?
Would we ever Fake Claim Doctor on Day Two?
if i were scum and saw that we had a two-shot RB
and there was a miller claim (implying cop).
i would assume there is no doc.
cop + doc is totally broken, especially with a weak RB.
cats, as you can see I thought Screens claim yesterday was fake. And it would likely be of little consequence to him because he’s known to be lying town, as a strategy. As mafia he could easily claim Doc to out the Doc, as he he claimed to clear you D1.
I thought I was the Town protective, and still think it’s viable as the only protective needed in this set-up (if it’s just 3 mafia, with a Goon, a 2-shot Roleblocker, and something else). We’ve both seen games where BG WAS the Town doctor role.
It’s that there was no kill last night that changes my mind. I agree with 2 mafia dead mafia would want to put in a kill. I agree Mantis was NOT the target and that as claimed Doc Screenplay should have been. That he’s alive is troubling, but his role claim today actually makes better sense than mine flavour-wise. What gives me the most pause are all the claims including his where there’s likely only 1 mafia left - I’d guess a JOAT. AND, yes, it still bothers me there’s apparently no alignment Cop, but I could see the GM adding it in as the negative utility it’s been.
VC 3-6