Chosen - GAME OVER

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

Thanks? I get that I’m the newbie and all but the amount of talking down from some of you is somewhat illuminating. I wouldn’t be worried about how I look if I were you, given the laziness behind some of your votes. But I am going to agree with muffin here - it’s almost too obvious for it to be truly damning.

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

Can we get a vote count? I think I have a sense of where I’m leaning towards.

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

The reason I asked is that for some reason that’s what I remember hearing about your playstyle, that you tend to seek out townreads first. However your hobnail boots post seemed weighted towards scumreads, while you haven’t actually voted any of them.

Which post are you referring to here?

[Key]

This one:

whoever is town in {eddie,nsg,alisae,cupcake} should start being town imo

could you describe why these people specifically?

Different reasons for different players. And key should have been in that group.

Eddie’s first post or three felt empty to me, like there was nothing evaluative going on.

I don’t remember why I called you out. I think I might have intended to put Key in that group rather than you, because I wanted to see more posts from her.

alisae’s posts have also felt kind of empty - like it’s all positioning and no testing or evaluating, except for the thing about you choosing scum. And katsuki’s countertrolling of muffin gave me no alignment vibes at all. There are some stances there, but I don’t get a sense that he believes them.

zmuffin and metal sonic have stances, which is something, at least. I don’t expect either of them to be easy to read here.

And Andres is a townread.

[Key]

You’re pretty easy to read plus someone said something about you re TM. Might’ve mentioned you prefer town but I can’t remember if they said so specifically. Might be mixing you up a bit with postie on that front but she wasn’t in TM.

NSG gut.

Postie was in my team in TM. But I’m pretty sure people also mentioned North’s preference for town in TM, which was why I wondered why you included me as someone you know something about but not her.
Now that I think about it, Postie and North were both in White Flag though, so if you forgot Postie was in the event it makes sense that you wouldn’t remember much about North.

Does gut mean “I have reasons that I’m reluctant/too lazy to explain” or “I just think so”?

[Katsuki]

I didn’t read WF. I happen to have heard certain things about your team in particular.

Gut is hard to explain. It’s like how I can read Mina correctly every game despite never reading her wallposts. It’s also how I can read certain players in under a minute (eg. DGB).

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

This one:

whoever is town in {eddie,nsg,alisae,cupcake} should start being town imo

could you describe why these people specifically?

Different reasons for different players. And key should have been in that group.

Eddie’s first post or three felt empty to me, like there was nothing evaluative going on.

I don’t remember why I called you out. I think I might have intended to put Key in that group rather than you, because I wanted to see more posts from her.

alisae’s posts have also felt kind of empty - like it’s all positioning and no testing or evaluating, except for the thing about you choosing scum. And katsuki’s countertrolling of muffin gave me no alignment vibes at all. There are some stances there, but I don’t get a sense that he believes them.

zmuffin and metal sonic have stances, which is something, at least. I don’t expect either of them to be easy to read here.

And Andres is a townread.

This game is different, due to players hoping to choose their alignment.

I have three pretty good townreads at the moment, and I’m leaning town on zmuffinman though I worry about letting my guard down.

[_fferyllt (_fferyllt (muffins > cupcakes))]

you’re leaning town on me?

what do you think of MS’s good point about how scummy my avatar is?

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

Fun fact: that avatar’s gun drew one of the first rvs votes ever placed on me.

[Ellibereth (Elli)]

VC 1.6

Metal Sonic (3): Alisae, Key, Katsuki
Katsuki (2): muffins, Josh
Alisae (2): Metal Sonic, northsidegal

Not Voting (2): fferyllt, Andresmvb

WITH 9 ALIVE IT TAKES 5 TO LYNCH

DEADLINE IS AT May 24, 2018 3:00 PM (Europe: Paris), May 24, 2018 6:00 AM (America: Los Angeles)

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

VOTE: Katsuki

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

VOTE: Katsuki

[_fferyllt (_fferyllt (muffins > cupcakes))]

Unvote

(don’t think he’s town, just have something i want to do before a lynch occurs)

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

I want to be clear as to why I’m voting the way I am, so there’s no ambiguity. There’s not much to go off of, but I feel like Katsuki came at muffin way too hard for calling him out on something I thought was legitimate: revealing his initial choice in such a passive way and at a relatively late stage.

[Ellibereth (Elli)]

VC 1.7

Metal Sonic (3): Alisae, Key, Katsuki
Katsuki (3): Josh, fferyllt, Andresmvb
Alisae (2): Metal Sonic, northsidegal

Not Voting (1): muffins

WITH 9 ALIVE IT TAKES 5 TO LYNCH

[Katsuki]

Unvote, Vote: Katsuki

go hammer

[Katsuki]

I don’t feel like wasting anything more on this game and this is the last thing I plan on posting.

[_fferyllt (_fferyllt (muffins > cupcakes))]

if you’re town, cupcake, you should stop being a muffin

if you’re scum who’s just given up because the picking alignment thing sucks, then ok

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

muffin how do you feel about Josh?

[_fferyllt (_fferyllt (muffins > cupcakes))]

that he’s non-existent but that it doesn’t mean anything necessarily

something obviously happened that’s making him take time away from mafia in general

he’s in a poe pool but that’s about it