Well obviously that only applies if you’re alive tomorrow, if you’re town and die today then you aren’t setting yourself up for tomorrow. Kind of seems self evident. My point is, in a scenario where muffins is lynched today and we’re both still alive tomorrow, that doesn’t make me auto-scum. Even in a scenario where muffins is lynched and you’re killed (which I find very unlikely, but let’s say for arguments sake), I’m still not auto scum. Nor am I confirmed town if muffins flips as a blank vig, at least I don’t think I am.
Anyways, main point is that you should spend your energy refuting the points being made rather than refuting imaginary points that make no sense.
if muffin flips blank vig you are confirmed town 100% since ur the only 2 to claim shooting him.
in the scenario me you and GB are still alive you would 100% be confirmed town (cuz mafia would have had to kill josh) which would unfortunately make me seem most scummy even tho id know at that point GB was scum (I still am fairly certain he is town atm)
I mean…I’ll take the townclear, but it’s not really a true town confirmation. Like, FYPOV, I could still be scum lying about being a vig and have NKed Katsuki, right?
Nanook, you are completely confirmed town if Muffins is a blank vig. The only reason you wouldn’t be is if a town player was lying, which I really hope didn’t happen.
Hmm. Ok, I guess I can accept this. It still feels like something is missing, but ok.
So let’s lynch Muffins, try for the confirmed town. Force scum to either NK me and let you choose between GB and Dwilts or let there be a confirmed town on MYLO.
Fwiw, my “somebody has to be town so I’m putting GB in that spot” is diminishing with their continued absence. Always feels a bit off to me when someone gets mass townread and stops contributing.
no cuz heres the thing only you and _fferyllt have claimed shooting muffin
I have shot no one
the other 2 arnt vigi claims and therefor couldn’t have shot anyone
josh was shot by mafia
all of those circumstancially by claims have to be facts
if _fferyllt came up blank you would have to be an actual shooting vigi otherwise 1 of 2 things would happen
1 muffins wouldn’t be dead
or
2 josh wouldn’t be dead
so based on claims and common sense u would then be an auto cleared town 100% common sense this is true regardless of me GB or mylo being scum in this situation
just wanna put this in there that you are ONLY confirmed 100% as town if _fferyllt shows up as blank vig fyi
if he shows up as regular vigi u arnt confirmed town just wanna drive that point there simply because with that scenario _fferyllt would have shot katsuki (I messed up the names in my last post fyi)
and mafia still would have been able to shoot josh…
in that scenario odds are me or you is scum based on numbers however its also possible for any of the remaining players to be scum (assuming the supersaint mylo get nked and GB is all that’s left)
however if its me you and mylo left alive we lynch mylo on standard since he claims SS and if he is SS he chooses which one of us gets hammered…
if hes not SS hes mafia and town wins…
by the by I would highly doubt regardless of whos mafia that mylo is alive tomorrow because that would be a huge risk for mafia to take…
Yeah, it’s shit reasoning and I can’t really give it a meta excuse since Nanook is claiming a shot. I do think he’s right that it’s probably a bad move to shoot in general though since I personally prefer lynches over vigs, but that doesn’t make you scum.
Isn’t Elli’s whole gimmick to sit back, not touch the poop, and then declare who he thinks is scum with good accuracy? If he’s SS he does exactly what he’s doing every single time, I don’t really see why anyone would bother questioning it as town (especially if they KNOW Elli) since we already agreed SS claims are locked-in lynches D1. And even then muffin argued earlier that scum are going to not fakeclaim SS, I’m just having a lot of trouble understanding why this ever happens from a town!Muffin perspective and where he was going from this.
^ i’m sticking to this and will obviously take a step back and reread IF i make it to 3way lylo without mylo
i think we have to lynch within {muffin/nanook} today to confirm if either of them are a blank vig, and nanook is far more likely to be town in my opinion
muffin has scum equity, like I said i don’t think his elli suspicion made a lot of sense D1 and I’d like to hear why he’d speculate about scum!Elli. Dom is POE, I pretty strongly townread Mylo’s spitballing of a plan that he thought would 100% incriminate scum!him and continuing to try and gamesolve despite losing a partner.
