@Nanook, wake up. If you’re Town, you’re going to sink us. I don’t understand how you can have this much certainty and be so wrong. I also don’t think you’ve Scum read me right every time. But even if you had, you’re not doing so here, so it’s irrelevant.
Also, you’re right - maybe I shouldn’t use your tone to read you any which way, as you’ve been aggressive as either alignment. However, I felt at first that you were being harsh in a logical way. You were wrong about GTacc overall. But it wasn’t egregious. I mean, I reached a similar conclusion.
@ErikaFurudo, I’m getting totally the wrong vibes from you not coming out with some statements about how you are looking at the game after D1. It’s precisely what I did last game I was Scum - try to wait people out and see what I could argue for that would guarantee a win. I can’t say I think you’re the likeliest person to be Scum here, but if you don’t come out with some sort of plan and view after your second post, I’m going to be suspicious. You’re right that probably only one Scum was on the wagon, but that could very much be you. I’m still clinging to my TR of you. But not by much.
@Mantis, I’m having issues with your certainty about Nanook being Scum. It could totally be right - after all, I said that if Nanook came out swinging against me, then it would sort of make me turn negative on him. But it’s very much unlike you as Town. Beeboy made a comment about you being aggressive Scum - this vote and limited explanation doesn’t help. Why you are so sure that Nanook is the Scum? And who do you think is his partner?
@MetalSonic, I’m not following your argument at all. Can you explain what you mean about Beeboy PR Hunting? And how does that explain your vote on Mantis? I’ll give you props if you’re Scum this game, as your strategy would have been effective. But I’m going to be disappointed if this was the best effort you could forward as Town. Get in the game.
—
Okay, so, either (i) Mantis and Nanook are not a Team (they’re throwing suspicion towards each other, and Mantis put a vote down on Nanook), or (ii) they see the writing on the wall and are creating distance. Honestly, I really doubt they’re both Town. But I still feel like (i) is more likely than (ii).
—
This can’t be a coincidence right? Nanook said that we should “execute GTacc and then Beeboy and then we win and/or profit.” And that’s… exactly what happened. And they were both Town. This might be an attempt at giving direction to his Partner.
—
Btw, I can’t even convince myself that voting for someone on the GTacc wagon is the best choice. I don’t even know if it’s that helpful that someone off the wagon was the one killed. But let’s assume that Scum is trying to eliminate people that will make it harder for them to win - perhaps you would eliminate whoever had Scum pinned down? Beeboy was convinced that Mantis was Scum. OTOH, I’m a bit skeptical that all of the Town came out and correctly identified Mantis as Scum. Something to keep in mind.
