I’ll emphasize the “retracting it a bit early;” it looked like the push gained steam, then she dropped the push before the push-ee could respond (Phone’s time zone was already established). If pushing for pressure was the plan, I don’t see how it was effective. She could easily imply it’s to draw fire from a VT (a killer would do this since a VT is an unoptimal NK target, yet susceptible to 2/3 of the NKs). And then she just says that Phone’s scum with little stated reasoning.
Something in her behavior makes absolutely no sense imo. I’m pretty sure that there’s at least one scum within Phone/Sam, and I’m more confident in Sam’s guilt.
Oh, was what we were arguing about on D1? Oops, I retract this I guess lol. Sorry, I’m not used to this format. My point is, I did have reads back then, even though it may appear I didn’t voice them much.
From this, we can only conclude you’re not a killer roleblocked by GoldenGirl, not that you’re not a killer at all. This doesn’t make you any townier (or scummier) than before.
Who’d you execute, then? GoldenGirl only? You aren’t considering her gambit as towny at all?
I would, too. I actually find her gambit rather towny (drawing the potential kill to herself, making herself a good protection target). She dropped it before it became anti-town.
As for Phone, eh, I guess I don’t have an objection, but I’d rather execute Erika. As for Martin, I’m starting to seriously consider the possibility that he’s just really weirdly misguided… not sure about it, but he makes some sense, and he could have started on the wrong premises. Idk if I want to execute him anymore. VOTE: ErikaFurudo
I’m gonna let her reply about her reasons, but it won’t hurt to say that doing this as killer on D1 is a death sentence (which also means the killer loses the game). The real specialist would either end up flipping someday or simply CC and prove himself.
The day was ending within the hour, and already counter signaled the afk wagon to no avail. The suspicion should be on the people shopping for a wagon on people who will give the least resistance.
Though I’m maybe open to a move on erika. Not sure about that though because even though she called it was VT, killers don’t know who the other killers are for sure so if anything this could be more town-indicative of her than not.
It also feels like there might be 1 scum/kill in golden/Phone…but that feels like a weird thing to say because then that means for most of the beginning of the game there were 2 killers in the chat lol
Like, I think Luft’s entrance was scummy but a few select responses from him seem to be good. I don’t exactly feel like he’s trying to be deceptive, and more like he’s trying to be a town and be up-front with the truth in a sense.
The thing is I don’t think the specialist would CC (especially since they didn’t). That’s trading town’s only PR for only one killer, and that’s super not worth. If I were Spec (not saying I am or am not), there’s no way I would take that CC so early in the game. I’d wait for my flip to screw them or reveal way more info than town would’ve ever gotten otherwise lategame.
She went into this knowing that there probably wouldn’t be a CC, then both claimed and backed off during a time span where she knew he couldn’t respond. The whole reason that she did this is because she knew she’d back off of the claim going into it. It’d be a death sentence to do this as scum, which is why she didn’t stick with it.
