Popcorn Mafia

Completed Games Completed Onsite
#161

also @Cheetory6 editing posts to fix typos is allowed on this site, because all edit history is publicly viewable by everyone. just only fix typo stuff, not content.

in terms of reads i have

elli probably town
chess probably town
gtacc probably scum
gif… maybe town
starv… to be honest i don’t read most of his posts. idk.
i could see a scum in ds / starv but i dont have anything tangible to back that up with
screen… very mildly townie?
urist… very mildly townie?
not sure on keel
dont remember anything nanooks posted
not enough scum there

from any townie pov’s here, there are 5 town and 4 scum. so really, on average, you could straight up guess and have almost a 50% shot of hitting scum. so really, having a lot of scum reads isnt bad like a normal game.

#162

haHAAAAAAAAAAA

#163

if you shoot less than 2 i will be very disappointed and not confident town will win this
if you shoot more than 2 i will be impressed
so 2 is my answer

scum team is idk i just gave my reads go wild
at least two of them are josh and gtacc

im going to be one of the last 5 because i dont think anybody in this lobby is stupid enough to hero shoot, and i dont think anybody except maybe you is good enough to catch me as scum, and i dont think you’re going to catch me as scum because i am town and therefore i will not be shot before 5
chesskid is probably going to be alive because i town read him and you do too

i dont know who the other 3 will be

but jokes on u because if we go parity wincon we might not get to 5 xd

#164

@Key can you set a topic close timer plz?

#165

how do your reads line up with mine elli?

or are you being :secret: until people post?

#168

Oops sorry for that close just now - fiddly buttons on mobile! Adding a topic timer and then I’ll look at the ruleset for wincons.

#169

Doesn’t read StarV’s posts/ thinks there’s scum in me and StarV

Lolllllllllllllll

#170

My reads:
Scum
GuyInFreezer
Cheetory
Josh

Urist
DS

Nanook (based on the others seeming scummy because he hasn’t posted)

Chesskid3
Screenplay

gtacc

Elli
StarV
Town

I think Josh should be shot before LyLo which is tomorrow if elli misses… So if elli shoots wrong, that person should just shoot Josh.

#171

Players grouped are interchangeable

#172

yea its a cool setup concept

gives each player accountability

whoever chose to run this is a pre smart dude

#173

if Elli mis shoots, then with the exact same set of information available, I am unlikely to shoot accurately as well. other than one scummy slot being dead.

#174

lol there’s definitely 1-2 scum in starv gtacc btw

#175

LOL IT IS STARV AND GTACC

#176

when i read this i thought “this is the most scum v scum read ever given” and i scrolled up to see who made post 21… and it was gtacc

insanity

#177

do you feel like you disproportionately read starv scum (r.e. our convo about vid mafia stats last night)

#178

If @Nanook plays this setup it would be good to hear how his group does it.

I would have assumed parity by default and that seems more fair to me, since scum needing six dead townies to win seems excessive.

#179

well i don’t have a sample size big enough to answer that

but GTacc is my main scum read, StarV just has real bad associatives with him and his pbpa posting style is real real easy to fake as scum.

#180

also keep in mind this is the equivalent of like page 7 and im mostly just shitposting and forcing reads until real shit happens

2 Likes
#181

I like shitposting

1 Like
#182

Honestly, I feel like I’m super easy to read and some players have got it down pretty good. The fact that you vote me everytime I claim you’re scum doesn’t help your cause.

When we’ve both been town, which is once… I was scum reading you because you played badly, and you owned to that at the end of the game, now I’m scum reading you because you keep missing bits of strategy and timing which I can’t forgive in a strong player, your reasoning should be on point and unfortunately if it is just “shit posting”, you still deserve the read and the lynch (of course this game being a bit of a different situation with the gun).

Like, from an external perspective, I would have me as mildly town this game so far as there isn’t much to go off of, but my play is very town.