Popcorn Mafia

[StarV (NotanAxehole)]

I only have one completed forum mafia scum game.

Partition Mafia, OVER

The scum thread is pretty underwhelming, I mean, I basically said the exact same thing in the thread, that I think 2-0 or 1-1 are best

I actually wanted to troll you by finding an old mafiascum thread, but I never rolled scum on mafiascum.

[Josh]

Josh Maybe scumlean

[Josh]

Hi I claim scum

GTacc is my partner

please shoot him first then me

thanks

[Ellibereth (Elli)]

@Cheetory6
start stuff on a new line after [/quote]

@GTacc
[uv][/uv]
We’ll add a mobile button for that ASAP but site has to go down for it etc.etc.

[Ellibereth (Elli)]

Its strategically correct for Josh to be shot no matter what when the next incorrect shot after Josh loses town the game, and no earlier. If someone doesn’t understand why, @ me.

[GuyinFreezer (Ocean Blue Freezer)]

Why Josh @Ellibereth

[Ellibereth (Elli)]

I think he’s most likely to have highest accuracy percentage on the people likely to be left late game.

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

i dont think so tbh

You don’t “think” so?

You would know so lmfao

[GuyinFreezer (Ocean Blue Freezer)]

Ok skill level thing

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

You said that’s it’s a good scum play so likely not my idea lmfao that’s 100% a comment on my scum play

I mean, it wasn’t my idea, but still fuck youuuuhh

[Ellibereth (Elli)]

anyone expecting high effort out of me this game is probably going to be disappointed
(probably a good precedent to set for on this site tbh!)

Ignore chesskid, that’s part of the goal (do whatever’s fun).

I’ve been ranting about this to different ppl for a while but I think a big problem r.e. mafia for loooads of ppl is that the winning line and the fun line are different. Been brainstorming solutions zzz.

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

If I were in the gun position I would shoot @GuyinFreezer. I think @Urist could also be scum, but if I’m wrong, I think Josh having the gun at lylo is optimal, which telegraphs the play for @GuyinFreezer . So I’m basically just assuming if worst case scenario, GuyinFreezer is a better shot today than Urist.

The comment about josh having the gun at lylo is weird to me, because if he’s scum he’s never getting the gun.

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

oh god quote formatting is different here
what have I done

So you click the reply button and then the little chat bubble in the top left corner

[Josh]

Yes, but also more than town read accuracy, I’m also v good at scum. So theoretically, I am a threat to end game if I’m scum, and also have >>>rand reads, so on principle I’m the best shot.

though I just want to say this while Elli’s alive: I don’t necessarily disagree that the “optimal” play is to shoot me at the day before lylo (making it lylo when i shoot), but I will never advocate for shooting me and I will always hard push to shoot who I think is sucm. That’s just how I play. Someone shooting me is one less scummy slot I get to flip. Saying this while Elli is alive because he can confirm this is not scummy of me to say / do.

[Josh]

and i feel pretty good about being able to find the last 1 or 2 scum. but if we get to lylo and haven’t flipped 1-2 scum yet, don’t think i’m good enough to shoot 4 scum in a row. its unrealistic. so just scumhunt now.

[Josh]

oh

@Key and i guess @Ellibereth as staff

last time i played this setup, it was ran where all townies had to die except the final gunbearer, but i think the “proper” way to run this setup is just the normal parity. dunno. which are we running with here?

[Josh]

also just throwing this out there
last time i played this (again, as scum) our strat was to hard bus a lot and just get super townread. because scum don’t have a night kill, being super town is fine you don’t need to explain away being alive. just keep that in mind, i am focusing on individual reads more than associatives here.

[Cheetory6]

thank you for fixing my garbage whoever fixed my garbage
I’ll do my best to make less garbage from here on out.

Maybe I’m town

idk man your vote seems pretty SCUMMY to me

You don’t “think” so?

You would know so lmfao

yeah idk man.
was I supposed to read my rolePM?

Ignore chesskid, that’s part of the goal (do whatever’s fun).

I’ve been ranting about this to different ppl for a while but I think a big problem r.e. mafia for loooads of ppl is that the winning line and the fun line are different. Been brainstorming solutions zzz.

Think it’s mostly that I just need to work on my self control. I’m literally late to class as I’m typing this. Lol.

I think he’s most likely to have highest accuracy percentage on the people likely to be left late game.

I’d probably prefer to lynch Josh if I think he’s scum rather than because he’d be good with the gun tbh?

Like, I really can’t imagine myself compromising and lynching Josh if I thought he was town just because it might be more optimal than potentially giving bad town a gun?
If we do super well in the earlygame it might be different for lategame. I feel like that kind of logic would only really make sense to me at like… 4 players 1 scum and Josh is still alive.
idk if that makes sense?

before I go panic about how late I am, I’m approximately caught up and
my pile for a d1 shot atm is urist, starv [pending some homework], srceen and nanook.

rest of the playerlist is a combination of preferably not the D1-shot as I currently understand it and townleans.
though I’m trying to wrap my head around the no-nightkill and no-immediate-death after shot mechanic because shooting potentially strong town/strong scum earlygame could be good in some ways and bad in others? would need to talk it out more.

[Ellibereth (Elli)]

oh

@Key and i guess @Ellibereth as staff

last time i played this setup, it was ran where all townies had to die except the final gunbearer, but i think the “proper” way to run this setup is just the normal parity. dunno. which are we running with here?

@Nanook what you think/how does the group you play it with do it? (Reply without alignment bearing ty)

[Ellibereth (Elli)]

everyone let’s play a fun game.

1. Guess how many scum I’ll shoot.
2. Guess the entire scumteam (4 names!)
3. Guess who the last 5 people alive in the game will be.