And then like suppose it is 1 scum in C which it probs is, is it worth you and loltown Star to get probscum Urist or lurkerscum nsg? Like can they hide better in other groups if they have to redo it after A is purged?
I can never be confident about DS, but this just doesnât smell like Scum DS. And his argument about him putting himself in a disadvantaged position intentionally rings somewhat true. I mean yeah, groups are not voting blocks. But if you know youâre Town, and youâre in the largest group, how likely are you really of ultimately voting for yourself?
And Urist is absolutely capable of setting the game up like this and putting DS by himself. If nobody in Group C is Scum Iâll be absolutely floored.
Also, my argument is pointless? I get that you might discount stuff slightly because itâs coming from a player youâre suspicious of. But how can you be so certain that Iâm Scum this early? This is just not Town behavior in my book.
Shall we call it a Titanic move?
Honestly though, youâre scum, so itâs fine, letâs lynch this house.
Youâre wrong, so whatever. At least for the future Iâll know whether youâre just arrogant Town or grating Scum.
Iâm obv town, you werenât confirmed scum, then you started reaching pretty hard to respond to my comments.
Your entire argument is based on âwhat I think people would doâ and not based on posts from the game. Youâre so tied up in game theory right now. To me, that seems like obv scum move. Explaining why you theoretically wouldnât do things while theoretically others might is definitely not town play at this stage.
Iâm not buying the narrative of âIâm trying to figure out who would have done thisâ followed swiftly by âoh, thatâs cool, I might have done thatâ either. Which was why I suspected you to begin with in regards to your comments about set up.
Ugh
Youâre still wrong. You can justify it however you want, but it doesnât change that fact. At the end of the day we all try and reason through what we see in order to put a vote down, so itâs okay.
And itâs not a narrative. I am the type of player that writes stuff down hoping that some of it is of some use to someone in figuring out the game. If itâs noise, then people wonât focus on it, and thatâs okay.
You seem to be the type of player that completely discounts meta. Iâm not saying Iâm a huge believer in it either. But clearly itâs a different approach, and itâs not any more or less valid than your approach of focusing purely on what is said in the thread. But even if you just focus on what is said here, you donât seem to want to address any of the points I made about potential motivation or strategy, but rather âwhat Iâve doneâ, whatever that means. Well, I put a vote down for our group. How you reconcile that with your bogus theory that Iâm Scum with Chess I donât know. At least recognize that potentially one of us is Town, if not both.
UNVOTE
Big egos walking thru
Oh hey Iâm back
Could this andres/star stuff be scum theater?
Do the votes in this phase even matter? Itâs all gonna come down to what people post/vote in the 24 hour phase after this one.
Also I really hope @Ellibereth allows us to read all of the posts before submitting our votes otherwise scum could easily hotswap to another group and totally shake things up regardless of who they are voting for during this 72hour phase.
And if it is setup like that, where we have to submit post AND vote at the same time, then we need to go into the next phase with a unanimous decision worked out already.
I wouldnât do scum theater, I donât really know anyone in this game, so I could definitely see why Andres would want to pick on me as scum though.
I mean, I might do scum theater, but if I did, it would not be with Andres, I mean⊠It would be so obvious to everyone because of our pre-existing relationship.
Who is Andrius?
This is the same argument that Urist used against me earlier btw. Urist-Star connection noted.
Are these your actual reads or a hypothetical?