Parity Cop 9'er (3, 4)

[Nanook (Clem)]

You did use the word holistic though which is near and dear to my heart so props for that.

[ActionDan]

ok but in this case if you compare your strength of read on me today vs reads on non-town reads of D1 there’s a palpable difference in strength. And why is that?

your P.O.E didn’t decrease, since only your town reads died. Did Tommy/StarV/Tn become townier? Did I become scummier?

[Nanook (Clem)]

You became scummier, I have confirmation those TRs were correct, and I have an easier pool to figure out. Also helps that TN came in and was very tonally town at start of day today, which isn’t enough to move him out of my POE completely but does make me want to kill him less.

[Nanook (Clem)]

Well, tbf, you didn’t become scummier so much as I’m paying more attention to how you were being scummy previously. If that makes sense.

[ActionDan]

I’m paying more attention to how you were being scummy previously.

regale me.

Also I did not detect Tn being tonally town at all.

[Nanook (Clem)]

Shitty case on confirmed town player = bad dan.

Disagree on TN, think his start of day was pretty good. I’m not 100% locked in though, if you think I’m giving tn a day pass too easily I’m open to dissenting opinions.

[tn5421 (Neopolitan)]

i would probably be sus of you if you locked me that easily in any case

[Nanook (Clem)]

I mean, maybe I need to be clearer: I’m not locking you town. You’ve just done enough tonally at the start of the day that I’m less interested in killing you today than I am dan and star, in that order.

[Nanook (Clem)]

Maybe I’m overselling things a bit but tbh I felt/feel like I sort of had to/have to in order to get the ship pointed back in the right direction

[StarV (NotanAxehole)]

Actually, Nanook, you and I all ended up arguing that Dusk was Town. I took way too long - Nanook was much more consistent, and so were you. It’s possible to some extent that one of you was TMI’ing, but it is spectacularly unlikely (I think) that the both of you are the Scum Team. It just does not seem like it. So I will assume for today that the two of you are just Town.

Hey!

Me too

[StarV (NotanAxehole)]

Andreés is town, M2H is town.

I think StarV is the best bet for scum. There’s been an overconfidence with his read on me that’s unnatural. And all he’s done is repeat it.

I don’t think StarV and Tn are scum together. And out of Tommy and Nanook I think Nanook is more likely. But that’s a lot harder to sus out

I’ve confidently listed you as scum in all my Mastroshka lineups. Hey… They also happened to be winners.

[StarV (NotanAxehole)]

#hashtag

[StarV (NotanAxehole)]

StarV, Nanook, Andres and Tommy are TTTT

[StarV (NotanAxehole)]

#gameover

[StarV (NotanAxehole)]

…s mind, and I’m not quite sure why that is. VCA? not really that relevant when I wasn’t even here EOD and didn’t dissect Dusk’s play at the time or engage with it. That’s very poor and narrow-minded for a townie Day 2.
It’d be easy to say we should lynch tommy first because he’s voted erratically or what have you but to my mind I can see Nanook’s play fitting a scum pattern.
That’s my bit on Nanook. From a holistic standpoint, I’m more concerned about Tn/StarV. I don’t think either has been playing reasonably this game, and unlike nanook this is the 2nd time they’re participating in a mislynch. I have to iso them some more and think more critically to make up my mind. As I said before though, I lean StarV as most likely scum for what looks like complete abandon of reason throughout the game.

I can’t make a case against Nanook

Let me make a case that puts incredible shade on Nanook without me directly going there

Oh wait, actually, ignore the rest of my post, StarV and TN are most likely to be scum.

Actually, StarV is my top scum read.

Did I read that right? Because it sounds like a load of scummy scummy bullshit. If you were town, wouldnt you just come out and say StarV and TN are scum?

[StarV (NotanAxehole)]

I mean, let’s stay focused on the prize guys, I don’t want you all to run off and lynch another Duskfall when the poe is clearly defined.

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

VOTE: ActionDan

@Ellibereth

[Ellibereth (Elli)]

Votecount as of post #1158

ActionDan (4): StarV, Nanook, Tommy2Hands, Andresvmb

Not Voting (3): ActionDan, tn5421, M2H

[Ellibereth (Elli)]

@ActionDan has died, he was Town.

Send night actions/lists.