You know, my reasons for TR Tommy are not that I just see that he was right about Dusk and that’s it. It’s about how the game has evolved.
I just… don’t even know what I am supposed to say to this. I can’t argue against this nonsense.
-
FMPOV, no scum on the dusk wagon means Andres/Tommy team exactly. Is that more likely than the other extreme of two scum on dusk? I don’t think so. So safe money has bare minimum one scum on Dusk, possibly two but almost definitely one.
-
You’re almost definitely town. DS is dead. TN has a scummyish vote, but is tonally townie, so I’ll revisit him tomorrow if necessary but don’t really want to kill him today. Star’s defense of his hammer today seemed too weird to be scummy to me–I think someone, maybe Andres?? had a differing opinion, but yeah, seemed like a weird defense for scum to make to me. The only reason I was townleaning Dan D1 at all was because of the sass, but that’s kinda silly tbh and other than that he’s done essentially nothing that looks townie.
Now, this has the caveat that my short track record with Dan isn’t amazing, but I trust my POE enough that I’m confident in this, and for fucks sake we have to start pushing this game in the right direction and nobody else seems to want to do it so here we are 
This is a horrible misrepresentation of my posts. Like seriously.
There’s already three votes on Dan and I am more than happy to hammer. You really shouldn’t be complaining about how no one wants to push the game “in the right direction”.
lets play the hypothetical game, if dusk had been scum then it would have been the correct move for me to continue pushing him no matter how much he pushed me to reconsider.
ofc he was town and we know that now, but I didn’t have access to that info prior to him flipping so I had to work based on my scum read of him (which I was starting to reconsider until starv came in and hammered dusk)
assuming that town has to have the 100% correct read 100% of the time is bad because you will never always be right unless you have tmi or you are literally playing with robots.
yes I had an incorrect read but it was a read that over half the game (and DS!!) had so no you do not get to come in and try to discredit me for that.
Yeah, and where were we before I started pushing it that way?
Oh, that’s right, one vote on Dan and playing the “MAYBE WE SHOULDN’T KILL ON THE DUSK WAGON THO” bullshit game.
Look, I do think you’re town cause this would be such a massive improvement to your scum game in such a small time I’m ignoring that possibility, but even you’ve gotta admit that your hedging at EOD without unvoting looks kinda sus in a vacuum.
Also, this was in response to a question about how I narrowed to Dan. Relaying my thought process at the time doesn’t necessarily reflect my thought process now, as I think we’re at least closer to playing a healthy game.
I appreciate that you are getting defensive about being wrong. It makes me think that Dan is almost always Scum here. But you are making it sound like TR Dusk was impossible. Even from my POV, when Dusk was way off about DS and me, and accusing me of having a bullshit read, even then I was able to change my mind. I am not assuming that Town have to have correct reads 100% of the time. That’s… clearly not the case.
okay ive literally read dusk wrong in every game ive ever played with him barring one and atp my strategy going forward is to literally play the reverse card on whatever I think duskfall is but with that said…
can you not see how trying to discredit my reading ability when I am one of the only people pushing you is kind of scummy.
No. And I am not discrediting your reading ability in general. We have not played enough for me to make general statements about you or your skills. But I am discrediting your read of me because it’s wrong and you should re-evaluate.
yes but only if you can’t see how my progression is natural which I think it is.
tbh it was like 5 am and DS was also on dusk and dusk literally went back on every read he gave the entire game in favor of pushing DS and I didn’t want to vote DS if this was becoming a DS/Dusk 1v1 so my strategy was literally to go to sleep and figure it out (because I thought scum!dusk was baiting me) when I waked up bc deadline would be at 4 pm but then starv came in and hammered dusk so rip me.
This slap fight is unproductive today, and you should both either stfu and can it until tomorrow or build the worlds most amazing game breaking case.
I want to hear about this
The lynch today is settled I think. This is essentially me trying to get my thoughts out there before Night.
Are you serious right now?
Sure but in a vacuum, the fact you had that progression and didn’t unvote even though he was at L-1 could, to some, look scummy.
But this isn’t productive, cause I very much doubt you’re scum, so let’s kist
Chalk it up to an honest town mistake and move along.
Also just skimming the bloodlust is palpable so let me say this.
Fair