MHA Mafia Game Thread - Game Over

Yeah lol, you pushing that to death was so weird to me that I thought you must have been scum for it but you were also leading town so hard. Fair enough that only a couple of people could really catch you on it though.
I think someone was speculating Srceen TMI based on him also thinking about how GTacc as a player would act, which was what really blew my mind

What makes you think they are only trying to solve mechanics?

Also I would have done the same as town sans that meta

Because with the limited information, along with a lack of context, it appears that they donā€™t care about divinging the alignments of players, but rather the alignments of mechanics. Mechanical alignments are a ficticious thing to divine as it requires knowing what the host would do.

you got context itā€™s beginning of game

Hm

I meant the context of what they were focusing on previously.

1 Like

I think the thing here is that you are thinking people who look at mechanics like this are automatic scum. That is not the case, this player is town. The reason you can see heā€™s town is because he isnā€™t talking about just information you have in the game, heā€™s trying to solve with the mechanics instead of just trying to figure out the mechanics. Itā€™s also early in the game where people donā€™t have a lot of access to other information, and the fact that the player is talking about this in this post shows that the game just started.

Letā€™s talk about this one.

What is the player actually trying to say?

What do you mean by ā€œsolve with the mechanicsā€?

aka solve the alignments of people who have those mechanics instead of just trying to figure out who has what role

That feels really odd and more of reading what the host would allow to be town/scum.

The player is trying to tell another that they think there is a difference between a supposed echo, and a supposed pressure.

Without meta it seems that deciding whether miller claims should be lynched or not is pretty arbitrary, especially in a game thatā€™s a mixture of players who donā€™t normally play together, or with a player like GTacc who plays across several communities that you canā€™t predict so easily.

Okay. Now with the second post I donā€™t expect you to know this which is why Iā€™m going to tell you a secret about town.

Town are uninformed, dumb, and over think things. Scum want to push an agenda, while town wants to solve. Because of this, scum will often post simple/complex posts that are easily understood. They are designed for people to understand what they are talking about.

Town will post confusing posts. They will over think things, over complicate stuff, or make confusing statements;which is what leads to posts like this. In this post, the person is over complicating what they are talking about. It is not easy to understand what they are talking about. Because of this, they are town. This is the exact same reasoning I used to clear Cloned this game because their statement about not being sure about his opinion because orange agreed made zero sense.

like what does echo or scummy echo even mean lmao

What is the player trying to do here jake?

I think they are mentioning a conflict, pretending like they dealt with it in this post, then going on to vote another player while suggesting others to lynch.

In this post, you get a little bit of context if you read between the lines. It appears that player one asked them a question about those two other players. This person responds with while it is important, I think they are both town.

How does this make sense at all from a town perspective. Why would it be important if they were both town? It is clear that this player is trying to dodge it by acting like it is important and then proceeding to down play it by saying they are town.

What do you think about this post jake?