MHA Mafia Game Thread - Game Over

I’m at a loss.
and
I think today could possibly be a do or die day for us.

1 Like

Ok, wow, a lot of stuff has happened since the thread got closed.

I saw some suggestions that the vig on Doggo was NK? I don’t think it’s likely. Doggo claimed Bakugo half way through day 1, if they were the target and NK had a day vig, then Doggo would’ve been dead yesterday. Also if I’m right about the mechanics this does not align with flavor.

I think gonna spend most of today NK hunting. I was leaning towards it being Jake, but since we aren’t getting a flip I definitely wanna get a more solid read on that. Also wanna look at who was around at the time of the vig shot, maybe I’ll find some leads there.

VOTE: deadbananas

I want to do this now. I don’t have any better ideas at this stage.

My logic here is: with Jake’s death, the shot would have most likely ended here with a lot of players vocally pushing for this as an alternative. I think DB benefits the most from Doggo’s untimely death, and so I think this needs to be flipped.

I had some lingering suspicions about Orange, but I think it would be kind of silly for Orange to both vote Doggo and turn around and whack him, knowing (if he was Scum) that Doggo is Town. This is just speculation I admit, but it just doesn’t seem sensical.

Thank you for scum claiming.
We discussed Dog was Framed.

I think that’s a joke Seth hahaha

It was really only 4 picks technically.
And do you think Srceen!Scum?

@orangeandblack5
You say to re-evaluate Arete but you really should be re-evaluating Deadbanana’s.

1 Like

doggo suspected fire kitten and andres. He also seemed to think andres was lying about “forgetting” that game i linked when doggo mentioned it. Or am I simply projecting my own vibe on him idk

Role was arsonist and it was orange.
I thought they was 3p and an actual day vig counter claimed them.

After seeing a couple posts talking about them like town i went back and reread. Then seen I was wrong in that thought. They are town.

The other thought process could be who had second amount of vig votes.

yeah i didnt read much from that time, only vote i recall is from orange on jake

Seth and I both voted deadbananas too.

bet

#2282 and #2156.

I also put DB as scum
but I also said I thought the shot should go outside of poe

You’re not asking me to respond, but I would argue that Doggo’s “suspicions” are not particularly instructive since he admitted up front to not having bothered reading the game. He did seem to question my alignment when I stated that I had seen his aggressiveness mostly from him as Scum, but I also said that I didn’t think that’s what he was doing here, and I also very much stated that I believed his claim.

Yeah well Doggo didn’t get to shoot anyone.

Also I don’t think it was a Mafia Day Vigilante, looking at what has happened I am lead to believe it is the work of a Mafia Redirector that can redirect both day and night actions.