MHA Mafia Game Thread - Game Over

[Arete]

no I caught that one

[Arete]

@ErikaFurudo

lolk dude i was willing to give you benefit of the doubt, but this is just open wolfing.

…what did you like about his EoD??

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

Oh yeah you’re right. GKB, Doggo, Seth and Orange is what I remembered.

[Seththeking (TrueSoulEnergy)]

Hope your all aware that if orange is scum, Jake is the obvious mislynch here.
DB has the highest chance to flip scum here.
Legit Above Rand Scum.

[Arete]

@ErikaFurudo

screen was a deciding vote on marshal and he had already suspected marshal before voting. what’s wolfy about that?

I mean the fact that he’d already suspected Marshal previously is a slight improvement but that doesn’t make everything about his treatment of the Marshal wagon not wolfy??

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

@DoggoPlays

I vote for deadbananas.

[Arete]

@Andresvmb

Oh yeah you’re right. GKB, Doggo, Seth and Orange is what I remembered.

ORANGE

THAT’S WHO I WAS MISSING

okay you have one townie person in your towncore

[Seththeking (TrueSoulEnergy)]

@deadbananas
2 questions.

1. What’s your top 3 Town reads in order (highest top, lowest bottom)
2. assuming Jake flips Town, who do you think scum is?

[Firekitten]

@Arete

• you
• Doggo
• GKB
• Seth
• someone else that I’m failing to figure out by comparing with the player list

why is that your towncore??? you have all the townie people in your PoE and all the weird ambiguous people in your towncore

Seth is mechanically confirmed themselves as town to me.
Doggo I had as town due to how they acted.
After thinking about it GKB claiming backup cop makes me think they are town, as they would of had to known there was a cop or they wouldn’t have claimed.
Orange is town due to a lot of factors

I don’t remember who else I took out because I just crossed off people I was pretty sure was town when reading that list of people

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

I feel kind of silly about this now, since then I would have been successfully pocketed. But it makes sense and fits with how I’m seeing things now.

[Arete]

@ErikaFurudo

if both wagons were mafia, mafia would break that tie so as to not out both players.

But Marshal was town so how is that relevant

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

@Firekitten

Doggo I had as town due to how they acted.

Can you elaborate on this a bit? Only because this is prior to the Day Vig claim. It’s probably moot now - there’s like no chance that if the claim is real, that Doggo is Scum I would argue.

[GoalkeeperBoss (Colin Coleman)]

What death would give us the most info to make an educated lynch

[Firekitten]

Dead

[Arete]

@DoggoPlays

my gut reaction is orange so that I don’t have to keep reading their 500+ posts, but well I can’t have everything my way always.

orange is one of my strongest townreads

[GoalkeeperBoss (Colin Coleman)]

I’m assuming you mean dead bananas yes?

[darth_tabor]

@Andresvmb

@darth_tabor this lends some credence to your theory I think. I am not inclined to believe that we have a Day Vig and a Night Vig amongst the Town. This obviously assumes that a Day Vig is not likely to be Scum, which frankly I would be amazed about.

Unfortunately yes. I’m inclined to believe Doggo, as their claim yesterday also seemed pretty clean. Day vig would definitely align with the flavor.
Dealing with NK is gonna be very annoying tho. I haven’t been reading for that so idk who it would be if we had one

[DoggoPlays (Don't Privatize Our Infrastructure)]

working on a public google sheets spreadsheet to keep track of my vote count now

[darth_tabor]

@Firekitten

Dead

I’d say Jake if they end up not responding. Gives us potential info on orange

[Arete]

I would say either Jake (once he gets back and clarifies his result) because of a general ‘shoot the counterwagon’ principle or Screenplay (since, well, they’re my strongest scumread)

no matter who you shoot you should wait for them to get back in case they can clear themself in some way