@ActionDan @GTacc @ErikaFurudo I need your input here.
Andres says dan very well might be scum but wants to lynch elsewhere firstā¦ then to bolster his argument he tags dan and asks him what to do. 
Anyway, I am fairly certain I know who the remaining doctor is, I donāt know their alignment and Iām considering outing them them in a plan that either guarantees us that they out themselves as scum if they donāt follow the plan or that allows us to likely find scum anyway. Thereās a certain risk of failure if mafia do some weird unexpected shit but I think that unexpected shit hurts them more than not in the long run.
When I said I might have a gamesolve, I meant a mechanical solve. One based on game logic, not one based on reads. Iām still trying to crunch shit and make sure Iām not missing something, and thereās a few pieces that Iām looking for from a few people today to judge the feasibility of this.
I think this is a terrible plan. If it wasnāt so transparently bad, I would think it was Scummy. You do realize the other Faith Healer is dead, the Vig has been used, and the Vengeful player was NKāed right? So the ONLY circumstance in which the Faith Healer can be used is for the benefit of Town. So even if it was in the hands of Scum (doubtful), your āplanā would ensure that potentially one player does not get NKāed one Night and instead, you focus the shot on one of the few useful PRās left.
If not a different player of course.
Okay sorry Iām around. Watching the uh, Key + Andres vs DS fight made me cringe so hard I just left and when I came back at like 5 AM gmt I realized phase was rip cause modkill.
Super upset about the Key flip tbh, she was my strongest townread, stronger than Tommy was when he was alive. Let me look back at what she said.
I wouldnāt call it a fight. I would call it game throwing.
I do stand by my read on you yesterday, I think you and Nuxl could be scum together. Unfort we had a modkilled townie because I think we had a good chance of lynching scum yesterday.
VOTE: Andres
Also iām still unsure about Nuxl, because if heās scum I swear his partners would have tried to get him subbed by now??
BUT M2H DID SAYNO SUBS SO MODKILL.
Nevermind I totally think Nuxl is scum again.
What
So I was thinking āWhy would scum keep an inactive partner? Why not push to sub him?ā if Nuxl were scum. But then I was like āWait M2H said no subs, it would result in a modkill if you needed to be subbed.ā So I canāt rlly clear Nuxl as town for not being subbed yet.
My top town read flipped town, let me now lynch their top town read.
Iām trying to understand this logicā¦
Please consider that youāre saying your top town read was so far off that her top town read is actually scum.
I understand that it doesnāt make sense, but townies arenāt perfect and her reads could be off. She also expressed doubt. I really see how it odesnāt make sense now but I really believe it.
She expressed doubt, not about her top town read.
In simple terms, Andres generally plays / believes people are playing in good faith, I donāt think he uses the DS situation as scumā¦ I guess you can make the argument that it was āforcedā on him, but I imagine he would probably mostly afk as scumā¦
Which brings me to Nuxl
VOTE: Nuxl
I donāt think this is the only good vote, but I do think itās a good vote.
I do think Nuxl could flip scum, Iām definitely willing to hop over to that wagon but I wanna see what others think about Andres again today. I REALLY think both could likely be scum together (scum!Andres pulling attention from inactive scum!Nuxl onto town!DS because DS seems to be iffy under pressure.) Correct me if Iām crazy and talking nonsense.
That being said Iām about 75% sure Nuxl is gonna flip scum.
DEPENDING on what Andres says about Nuxl I might change my mind.
Youāre going to try to convince me that youāre more than 75% certain Andres will flip town?
Now, I know youāre any combination of:
- Lying
- Delusional
- Mafia
If youāre 70%+ on anyone, you really should lock vote in and never moveā¦ Soooo Iām inclined to believe youāre lying here.