M16 Game Thread

Completed Games Completed Onsite
#3961

Catty flips scum

I’ve been the biggest advocate for killing her

You guys, can, in good conscience first that I’m town (buy of course I’d say that. But I’d argue scum would never have insentive to hard bus their own).

So while killing a scum you also help clear a town.

Brandon will probably be dead.

But I totally trust you and I’d be willing to bet you trust me.

I think kaylee has town but that also has little merritt to it. I trust Brandon’s read on quin…

That leaves two. Gg.

I’m doing my best to avoid an emotion baised OMGUS

#3962

Lol are you just dipping until you get clapped or town loses?

#3963

@GoalkeeperBoss

I’d like to see your thoughts on this

If we don’t lose its lylo the following day so I’d like us to form a plan before the maf kill removes one of us

#3964

Here’s the thing.

The fact that there is this much contention on this should show you everything you need to know.

1 Like
#3965

Wait hang on

Are you voting ek for mechanical reasons or scumminess?

Cuz I thought consensus was that cat is a much better kill based off of scumminess

#3966

Hang on smth occurred to me brb

#3967

Found it

#3968

Actually, I’m going to do a complete 180 on this

GKB was the one who first suggested cat was twtbaw; as such, this really scummy claim by cat actually makes sense with them both as scum - GKB can avoid having to claim a PR while defending cat by arguing it’s twtbaw.

#3969

Maybe I’m tunneling too hard but rn I see a GKB/cat/? scumteam

Anyways I gtg, will be back tomorrow

Whatever you don’t put anyone in hammer range (which is theoretically 2 votes)

#3970

Dang…looks like I missed some actual discussion.

Lets sleep on this and figure something out tomorrow.

#3971

Okay wait, while voting EK May be the best way to proceed statistically, I don’t have a strong reason to believe EK is mafia.

Cat is still the right move, absolutely no voting EK. No. Why would we vote someone who we THINK is town just because they aren’t confirmed when we could vote out someone we THINK is scum. The point is to kill the mafia, not play a guessing game.

1 Like
#3972

In fact I think this latent push on EK is probably scum trying to convince town to vote out a town instead of a scum so we lose for sure.
We vote out cat, I’ll just wait to place my vote so we don’t hammer early

1 Like
#3973

Ummm… this entire game is a guessing games.

We just try our best to make educated guesses. We are guessing that EK is town and cat is scum. But we have all played this game enough to know that we are wrong a lot of the time.

What voting EK does is allows us to be wrong about him and still have another day in the game. Where as, if we are wrong about cat…its game over.

#3974

But this makes the fundamental assumption that catty is infact scum. EITHER way they have to be scum for us to make it another night.

So if you feel confident enough to kill me to kill catty, why not just kill catty.

#3975

Because we kill two people with one vote, purely mechanical

#3976

At this point I kinda do think catty is scum based on her nightly moves and weird claiming stuff, but I also think u are as well, if u flip town, kill catty, oh well life moves on.
If ur scum u take down Brandon or me probably then leave us to WIFOM if catty is scum based on how hard u are bussing them rn

#3977

But that applies tomorrow

It also applied on the very first night.

#3978

I think it’s cute that no one suggested this until litten died.

#3979

What does that have to do with anything lmao

#3980

I think in a scum!ek situation we need to be looking at kaylee and laser I think
There’s some early game posts I think I remember, I’ll try and grab em later today