The tl;dr summary of this post is rather than engaging with the case against him, he’s trying to make me feel like pushing him is silly
I agree that being dismissive in that way is usually >rand!scum, but I can also sorta turn your argument against you in that it’s tonally completely different from all of the scumgame quotes that you shared!
The closest one is Danganronpa, and that’s still a different sort of joking attitude! It doesn’t match his town attitude either, but neither one really has the same sort of joking! (And they are definitely cherry-picked quotes!) Are you going to try to say that it’s impossible to find an Icibalus game where they joke around as Town?!
TL;DR: I wouldn’t intrinsically label his posts here as scummy if you two know each other and have a rapport!
what would you have expected him to say instead. Something like “your concerns are valid and I appreciate you, please tell me where I look fake?” because I doubt he’s the guy that does that. Or did you simply think he’d be more angry and reactionary (kinda like how Zone was).
I can see where you’re coming from though. He at this point, ought to state his piece in anycase.
I am not able to be super active on Thursdays. VOTE: Deadbananas
Unless I see something else while rereading the thread
Me?
Reason?
Votecount as of post #1058
deadbananas (6): TotallyNotKyubey, Icibalus, Valerie, Geyde, Wisp, Ari_2412
Icibalus (3): Marshal, ash4fun, Arete
Ari_2412 (2): deadbananas, IronicDeadBird
bepwei (1): Quin
Marshal (1): REM
IronicDeadBird (1): bepwei
Not Voting (2): EricKline, Chemist1422
What’s going on?
idk iso the mod posts, and tell me what you see
@Wisp @REM @TotallyNotKyubey @Geyde @Chemist1422 @Arete
Potential targets for tonight (assuming a Deadbananas lynch, otherwise you can replace EricKline with Deadbananas) are listed below!
Icibalus
EricKline
quin
Ari
IronicDeadBird
Any thoughts on who I should target?! (I’m obviously not going to say my final decision in the thread!)
If you have dirt on ari, could you just state it?
I don’t know what he’s supposed to see, but I don’t think I will be able to spot it… So could you lay it out maybe?
Ici > Ironic > Quin > Ari > Eric
from most likely to least likely to flip wolf in my opinion
2 Likes
i dont really
Im stuck between is he pushing things maliciously, or are those just his thoughts
meta-wise its probably the latter
but I aint locking that in any time soon
^ this, except maybe swap ari and quin cuz I don’t know anything about either 
(To arete’s post)
I don’t think you should shoot Eric, quin, or ari, but I agree with arete’s list of who is more likely to flip.
omg stahhhhhhhp
I would shoot either Ari or Ironic. Not Ari on a scumflip of bananas though.
My read on Eric is waning as well and I really don’t believe that its a masonery without mod-confirmation.