Point one is fair, but just seeing you play like this just doesn’t look town at all for me.
And point two is kinda fair, but like why has it changed? I’ve done the same stuff for pretty much all these days, I don’t see why my play this day suddenly rings scum for me. By the way, I can share some scum games of mine if you’d like to compare my play from here to there?
So, can you provide us with ideas to do tomorrow then? If you ‘accept’ a lynch, that means from your POV we’re going into tomorrow in LYLO! What do you want us to do then? Who should we be suspicious of?
VOTE: elli
Oh, and
VOTE: Nanook
Because you started OK, with some broad reads…and then never developed from there, you’ve just sort of stayed in the same “claimed PR+consensus townread are town, everyone else might be scum” place. That’s a fine place to start, but you can’t really spend 2 days in it, or it starts to look scummy (to me it does, at least).
Sure. You, Elli, and cats. I feel like that should be clear, from my posting, that those two and you are where my suspicion is.
That is fair, but why would that be scum indicative for me?
Because it’s directly contrasted to you in Brass and Shrapnel, where you went from wide view to slowly zooming in on things and narrowing them down, with good success I’d add.
Especially for a Milo that thinks this could be MYLO, I’d be expecting to see more genuine urgency from you, rather than a reads list that has barely changed since D2 and is as milquetoast as they come.
Okay, you have made your thoughts on Mylo fairly clear.
Can you give us your toughts on me and Ellie Please?
What are you seeing as scummy in our play?
Who are your strongest town reads?
Why?
Cheers
That was because of the set-up being open and easy to understand. Here, I don’t know the set-up and there’s far more players too.
And I don’t think this is MYLO at all, if we mislynch today we’ll likely go into LYLO tomorrow though.
I’ve done both those things already. I suggest a quick ISO, shouldn’t be hard to find. You’ve even engaged with my thoughts on you already, I believe, so you should at least be aware they exist.
Strongest town reads right now are Elwood (obviously), andres, and I’m feeling pretty decent about urist.
So…why have you been pushing that idea then, and saying it might be??
I swear you’ve said it might be MYLO today, am I going crazy?
I don’t know how to iso from my phone, but I’ll figure it out when I get home. I’m reasonably sure that Milo was pushing forward the idea it might be MYLO today at some earlier point though.
It would’ve been MYLO if we’d lynched a town player yesterday.
I do ask people to repeat themsleves, sometimes that can trip up in doing so. 
The ol’ E team eh?
I’ll start with Erika. I had bad feelings about her play on d1, and she’s really done nothing to assuage those feelings, since she’s just been lurking since I joined. I’m not sure why people keep bringing up her hammer on a townie as a good thing. She seems like a very confident player, and I don’t doubt that she’d be able to pull that off as scum. Her push on Val early day one was not great, and to me it read like scum trying to push an easy wagon. Val’s first post* was super duper cringy and weabish, but I didn’t find it scummy. What I did find scummy was Erika using that first post as a reason to start pushing Val*. I feel like Erika saw low-hanging fruit and decided to gobble it up. Then her continuation of the push* is weird because she accuses Val of struggling to generate content. I read d1 in about 10 minutes, I feel like I can confidently say that there was not a whole lot of content to be had from anyone. She also accuses* Val of lurking, but a) it was still kinda early in the day, and b) Val had posted 3 times the day prior. (Side note, apparently Erika did not want to lynch Titus d1*, but ended up hammering her. While I don’t think that’s scummy, I do find it interesting that she hasn’t defended my decision to switch to Val yesterday). I could go on but I feel like I’m just going to tunnel and overanalyze her play. Suffice it to say that I think Erika is going after an easy lynch and that today she’s doing exactly what I told Andres I would expect scum to do if we didn’t lynch Val yesterday, that is sit around and do nothing because they don’t have to bother updating their reads. HOWEVER, if we do end up lynching Nanook and he flips scum, Erika would be cast in a much more positive light, so I’m ok with putting my Erika read on the backburner while we fry other fishes.
tl;dr: I think Val was lynchbait and that Erika was gunning for a mislynch all of d1 & d2, but if I’m wrong and Nanook isn’t actually town then I’m probably wrong about this too.
Next, Ellibereth. I don’t care for his play this game. I’m not sure what else to say. Very boring play that could easily belong to either town or scum. The anger here felt fake but I have no other complaints, really. I would probably be down for lynching Elli if not for the fact that he agrees with me that Mylo is scum. I feel like we’re not going to get anything substantial out of him so we’ll just have to base our read on whether or not he’s right about Mylo. And since I think he’s right about Mylo… you see where I’m going with this. If I’m wrong and Mylo is town, I’ll have to reconsider Ellibereth.
tl;dr: Elli is a ? for me, I would rather lynch Mylo first to see if Elli is right about that.
Finally, Elwood. I never really seriously thought he was scum. When I mentioned the possibility of him being scum in my discussion with Andres, I was merely using him as a hypothetical example of why nolynching is a bad idea. I had complaints about his continued tunnel on Val/Nanook, but other than that he didn’t seem particularly scummy. Obviously now that I know he’s town, I just think he’s being obnoxiously incorrect with everything he says. At this point I’m really hoping that Nanook is town only so that I can watch Elwood eat his words + some crows.
tl;dr: Worthless slot, hope he dies tonight.
Urist, if I was lynched today and flipped town, were would you go tomorrow, knowing it’d likely be LYLO?
yo mama
also someone else do the work here
people assuming 3 scum are sketchy
Do you think there’s two scum Ellie?