I mean I’m really not trying to argue the scum utility of my role, but it definitely would be useful for scum if you knew the entirety of it. Gtacc is trying to come up with a reason to townread me that doesn’t involve my reading of his slot and the logic is bad.
But you make the best arguments for why your role can be a scum role!
I’m guessing you were gonna mention how it works as a scum role if there’s a vig?
I was like contemplating not saying this because idk how this information could truly help town, but I doubt I’m ever going to use this part of my role anyway so here goes
I choose up to three people and they aren’t able to be protected that night or the night after
There’s also a logical inconsistency in saying your role doesn’t make sense as scum, cuz tbh it doesn’t make a whole ton of sense as town either.
Also the whole “scum lies” thing is a thing.
So like my role 100% has scum equity and Gtacc trying to make it seem like it doesn’t is super weird to me
i mean yeah there’s a lot of scum utility in this role
you didn’t say it was that night and the next night after too
he was basically saying that scum know who they’re nk’ing so only need to unprotect one person, not three, which is a valid point imo
i think it’s negative utility in general if you’re town tbh
Yeah I’m never using it.
Why would you ask this? Isn’t this your typical role fishing? Why wouldn’t you trust when AD says that there’s an aspect of his role he doesn’t want to out? I don’t get it.
—
#1328 - Gtacc insisting on this really makes no sense to me. It’s not even a comparable claim. I’m not the only one to raise this [Skitter in #1338]. Whatever, I’m seriously not going to have this discussion over and over. You have a view, I have a different one. You really don’t want to reconsider, so whatever. You’re wrong, that I can tell you.
—
#1363 is terrible from Erika.
This was in response to Urist in #1127. Dont know why that didn’t work out.
And this is in response to Skitter in #1068.
Hahahaha! Always man, always.
Beyond that game I replaced in? No.
Hm. You’re Town read is stronger than mine.
Okay, I see where you are coming from. I don’t play it like this only because I still think of myself as relatively inexperienced. However, I do avoid wagons with people I am Scum reading, so I won’t object to that.
I can see it both ways. It could be a townie saying “hey lets put this aside because I think you are town and im town and lets work together”, but I didnt really get that feeling from Mantis.
I know that Dan has posted a WHOPPING 26(!!!) times, but maybe instead of whining that nobody is helping you, you could find the time to look through the library that is ActionDan’s iso.
To answer your question he hasn’t claimed a buddy.
I don’t want to Town read Srceenplay purely because of his role, but aren’t Neighborizer’s usually Town-aligned? Is this a one-shot @Srceenplay? If you don’t want to share, that’s fine, since I don’t know what’s optimal here.
This is dumb.
psure there is a wolf in urist and cheeky. I think it’s cheeky, but it could go either way. If you are confident urist is town, then you should hang cheeky.