Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

[MetalSonic]

VOTE: Catspurr

The vote on MS seems contrived to me due to the format of the accusation ending with a ? and that some of the logic behind it relies on assessing _fferyllt/muffin’s two posts to be town. In the two times Catspurr has been accused of floating along by both Urist and Nanook, she has to yet to address either even when given a direct prompt by skitter in her #113. This reluctance to respond lends credence to their meta assessments neither of which I thought was particularly compelling at the time.

Very scummy

[MetalSonic]

Wait…
THEY’RE DIFFERENT PEOPLE?!

AFKD is town

[MetalSonic]

So I finishing reading the game and those are the reads

Needless to say, mantis and urist are town

So that leaves AD and cabd and judgemental

[Mental (Judge)]

@Mental can you talk to me a little? I don’t want to just lazily vote on you, if you are town.

Where are your thoughts at?

How do you feel about Urist vote on you? Where are your thoughts re Screenplay?

Sure, I can talk to you I think you’re town.

Urist’s vote on me I don’t give a shit about. I have him as town and he’s always been suss about me, so… I know you didn’t mean my emotions about it but I’ve had an all-day workshop and I find them exhausting plus I got a name badge with an ominously coloured dot on it so it follows that I am happy to share that my game has developed to a point where although I do have a pathetic need to be town-read when I’m town, I can cope when people see me as scummy.

Andres: I’ve never had a firm read on them and they could be really annoying town with a game style of endless conversational spirals and once having a read THAT READ CAN NEVER CHANGE AND EVERYTHING SUBSEQUENTLY POSTED CAN ONLY BE FURTHER PROOF OF SCUMMINESS. I have a slight town read on them as I think the annoyingness is a more towny trait. I’m suspecting they need to have a baseline read of me so that they can entertain the possibility that what I say is my motivation for posting something is in fact my motivation for posting something.

Screenplay: when they did their fake claim I watched (nb I was not in the game until much later) to see how such a behaviour is treated on this site. Apparently, with half-hearted meh. I could vote here today.

MS is meh. Cats similarly. For cats to be scum it would have to have been scum theatre. I need to think about this. Cats’ reaction to nanook was something I’ve not seen before.

Pyx’s game is surprisingly meh. So much so that it’s only the miller claim that has me town reading him.

Josh I don’t have a read on at the moment.

CABD is scummy and that’s where my vote is at. If I’ve forgotten anyone, sorry it’s been a long day.

[Mental (Judge)]

So I finishing reading the game and those are the reads

Needless to say, mantis and urist are town

So that leaves AD and cabd and judgemental

^um I find it hard to believe that you and screenplay are really both so dense that you think there is an AD slot that is somehow separate to me

oh, and the CAPS thing in my prev post ^ sorry I’m a little frazzled

[Mental (Judge)]

whoever is in MS’s account, please log out asap

[MetalSonic]

So you’re AD? Cool

VOTE: judgemental

[MetalSonic]

oh wait I already did that

At least it’s not just only because of your scummy avatar!

[Mental (Judge)]

No, this is genuine random from you!

[Srceenplay]

Screenplay: when they did their fake claim I watched (nb I was not in the game until much later) to see how such a behaviour is treated on this site. Apparently, with half-hearted meh. I could vote here today.

This is still I thing?

I think it’s safe to say it caught nanook.
Nanook tried to force it and couldn’t and ended up backing away from it at eod.
But
I believe it was mantis who took up the baton and continued with it.
Now judge as well.
Is this the only thing talked about in scum chat?

[Mental (Judge)]

yes, we find you fascinating!

[Josh]

?_?

why these 3 people?

[Urist]

I don’t think Nanook’s reaction to Srceen’s fakeclaim looks like scum v scum.

For one, Nanook took the claim for granted and asked for a CC. To me, that looks like scum who knows the claimant is town and therefore takes the claim at face value.

For two, Nanook never returned Srceen’s vote or suspicion. If it was an attempt to distance, I would expect Nanook to return a little bit of flak. Instead, he goes on the defensive.

There is the point that Srceen never really mentions Nanook after the claim convo dies down, and this could point to the whole thing being a sham. However, I still think it’s more likely that Nanook reacted poorly to a townie’s fakeclaim.

[MetalSonic]

yeah, screen is town, I said it above

Aren’t you glad your pass given to me yesterday returned positive interest?

[MetalSonic]

I want to lynch AD or whoever is in his slot

[Urist]

Technically I said it before you did.

[Josh]

what about me

[MetalSonic]

you are josh tier

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

I have had a thought about Cats’ alignment, and I am going to put it out there for discussion. What is the likelihood that Nanook as Scum would so obviously tunnel a Town player? Say Nanook succeeds in leading a lynch of Cats. What does that give him? Either he is arrogant enough to think he can survive it (which I don’t think he would have), or he is doing it for the massive amount of Town cred that it would give him to lynch a Scum player. I think the second one is more likely, and I am starting to think that it was a long-term play that would have benefited him at the expense of Cats (who he does not seem to care for much).

[MetalSonic]

Yea, maybe they are bussing