Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

Completed Games Completed Onsite
#3296

I also think we need to think about Urist wanting us to look away from the two to find Scum, until it was clear it wasn’t going to happen and he made the choice of helping lynch the coasting player. Unless you think #2548 from me is not genuine.

#3297

Ya … I guess I was thinking you were asking ppl if they got roleblocked. Since you said that you took the sleepwalking thing as a role block. But no one could have got rb

#3298

I kind of skipped over the fact that you said sleepwalking. My brain just went to … no role block

#3299

yeah at first I wanted to let Cabd live, so he could prove his role. he would have just been lynched today since that would have been impossible.
the last two posts you quote should tell you that i’m town. i argued strongly against the MS lynch all day, which was definitely the only reason why he wasn’t lynched yesterday. do you actually think i would do that as scum?

#3300

That comes into play for me actually ^ why argue against MS lynch. Makes no sense as scum

#3301

I think there’s Scum in {Urist, Srceenplay}. Given the strength of Srceenplay’s claim, I don’t want to lynch there. I’m also happy with lynching Josh, as I think his hard push for MS has proven detrimental to Town, and he could be Scum. Clearly Nanook was bussing Cabd D1, so whoever was around and didn’t hammer is also very suspicious. Urist holding back and helping switch the wagon over to Smilodon also stinks in my mind. And Pyx having made a stink about not helping to lynch Scum also sticks out in my mind.

#3302

He was arguing against a lynch against both of them. And if we flip MS, he knows we immediately flip Cabd, who had put himself in a horrible spot. So why defend that?

#3303

I also find it rather convenient that Cabd used his power N1 on Urist, who was happy keeping him one more night to “prove himself” when he was a 2-shot RB who probably used his power only once (on MS), and was probably needed to block Srceenplay. Strategically, that makes sense to me.

#3304

But fake claims on ms.

#3305

Exactly. And not Urist?

#3306

I
could

not

have

done

that

thing

to

Ms

that

scum

did

because

I

have

a

confirmed

action

and

there

is

1

scum

alive

ergo

I

cannot

be

scum

#3307

This logic is flawed. If you can coordinate with your Scummates, you don’t have to perform the action yourself.

#3308

Also, why are you so sure there’s only 1 Scum left?

#3309

BUT THERES 2 DEAD SCUM AND NEITHER OF THEM ARE FRUIT VENDOR OR SLEEP WALKER

#3310

because 4:9 would be retarded?

#3311

I don’t know if there is or isn’t, I just wouldn’t assume it’s the case. If we have a strong Town role, you might make up for it with more Scum than usual. I don’t know.

#3312

not really a thing.
but yeah, the fact that i corroborate Josh’s claim by saying MS wasn’t RB’d be Cabd means that Josh is cleared for sure.

#3313

So what are you proposing? And how do we know that you were actually Roleblocked? It’s impossible to tell, given when it’s coming out (which seems particularly well timed to try and move suspicion away from you). If you had informed us about this on D2, maybe that would have made it more believable. And you also seemed very sure that you “weren’t going to be NK’ed”.

#3314

Can the rest of Town chime in here?

#3315

I actually hinted about it in the QT last night, I said I had nothing to claim. I said this hoping that if I was nk’d, Josh and cats would put 2 + 2 together and get either that I was blocked, or not to read too much into what they thought my n1 result was.

Regardless of whether you believe me, either I’m lying scum and Josh is town, or I’m town and Josh is town.