I don’t look at other games.
And
Of course I reevaluate. I’ve been back and forth on my read of them this game a lot. I think I’m naturally inclined to scum read them.
But I think it’s just something tonal I pick up on all the time.
smilodon replaces AKFD. Please welcome them!
AD could be scum i suppose. probably didn’t have a good reason to think he was town when i was reading through and looking back at it he hasn’t done all that much really for as much as he’s been interacting with people
i havent been paying attention to votecounts or what wagons are on who tbh (somewhat unusual for me, but i just haven’t. who’s voting who hasn’t played a part in the way i’ve been forming reads here)
i don’t have a town read on mantis though
Thanks. I can’t really begin until tomorrow though. Am too tired and it is almost 11 pm here. 
Could be neither. Ie he could be town… but honestly I’m not sure
Oh just saw Urist posted. Let me read what he says.
Why is parsec voting Andres anyway… hm
find it fits entirely within*
he has a role pm of the red variety
Why do you say this?
Cabd replaces skitter30. Please welcome him!
Welcome cabd!
You don’t post for 5 days, then come back with this? This is the definition of coasting.
AD was picking up on some good stuff and seemed to be trying to figure out the game. I plan on rereading his posts but that was the impression I got back then.
As for Srceen… it’s not a strong read, but I feel like his push on Nanook has come from a town mindset. I would say that out of all of my town reads, I’m the least confident about this one.
is orchid a variety of red?
What was my push, I don’t remember.
I don’t see this. You fake claimed to clear Cats, joked that Cats was Scummy for role fishing (I say joked because the questions were valid and your claim was fake), and then said that you had a slight Town lean on Cats.
At this time, Cats was L-4.
Mantis then does a deep analysis of Cat’s posts, and comes to the conclusion that Cats is probably Town. You seem to move on, since no more posts from you reference Cats until… you vote Cats in #660, when Cats is at L-3, and after Cats writes a post that you call questionable. Now, the post is most probably not AI, since Cats has asked the same question as Town (in a game that you played in). So all in all… I don’t find your explanation to be particularly compelling.
I have another question for you. If you are Scum reading Mantis (I do not know if you are or not anymore, though you did have a vote on her at one point), do you think that Scum!Mantis would look to stick her neck out and write a detailed analysis of Cats’ posts to clear a fellow Scum player? I am thinking at most one of them might be Scum, but probably not both.