VC 2.6
Josh (4): Andres, Key, Alisae, muffins
Alisae (3): Metal Sonic, Josh, northsidegal
WITH 7 ALIVE IT TAKES 4 TO LYNCH
Josh was lynched.
He was a Mafia Goon.
NIGHT has begun
It ends May 31, 2018 10:00 PM or earlier at the Mafia’s discretion.
@Chosen if you havean opinion about keeping all the days in the same topic (as is now) vs. splitting topics a la https://forum.mafia451.com/tags/rbm pm me to let me know.
@Chosen
muffins was killed.
He was a Vanilla Townie.
DAY 3 has begun.
Deadline is June 8, 2018 2:00 AM
WITH 5 ALIVE IT TAKES 3 TO LYNCH
@Key, I think we need to protect Alisae. I do not think scum!Alisae votes for Josh there (or even lets it get that close). Unless you have some other read of the situation. It’s also very likely that Alisae is Chosen, purely based on how strongly Josh was advocating for the lynch.
Needless to say, you are my strongest Town read. So I will listen extremely carefully to everything you say.
My lynch pool consists of {MS, NSG}. From where I stand, NSG has some explaining to do. A lot of lurking, and the wrong votes every time. Interestingly, Josh never identified NSG as a potential suspect, going as far as to say that:
I am the only other person he dismissed as definitely Town. Which makes me think I am Vanilla, actually. In any case, that’s how I see the game.
VOTE: METAL SONIC
Good job now lets vote the person who claimed they got wolf.
sigh
i knew one day that that type of scumplay would get the better of me, but i didn’t realize it when it was happening to me
Andres, I agree let’s not lynch Alisae but
sorry what? Can you walk me through this one? I don’t understand where this is coming from.
Right now I’d really rather lynch North over MS. I’m struggling to see her as town by this point, and it makes me think she’s scum cruising on what people think she’d pick.
VOTE: northsidegal
my hat is only eaten if alisae is not scum
Josh being scum does not prevent alisae from being scum
I will however hail muffins > cupcakes, that I can do
Do I really have to spell this out? Muffin is gone, we voted together and relatively early on, on a similar read with a very strong impact to our position in the game. Alisae voted that way out of necessity - you voted that way out of an appreciation for the argument. If I thought you were scum, it would imply that I think that you jumped on a wagon at massive detriment to your Team for… what exactly? The downside of what just happened is particularly large, I would think.
On that note,
VOTE: NorthSideGal
VOTE: Alisae
Out of policy
And I have to eat my hat if she’s town so
I’m so tempted to lolhmmer nsg tho
Metalsonic or me has to do before LyLo
Like there should be no alternative to me and metal today
Even if we’re both town.
To be very honest with you, I am very much indifferent to the order in which we approach this. However, I do think it would be more interesting if we went for NSG first. If we go for MS, and MS flips Town, what do you suggest we do next? I really cannot see a scenario in which I vote for you, mostly because of how close we got to lynching you and how strongly Josh advocated for it. If that was an act of distancing, it flirted too close with disaster to truly make sense. So I am ruling it out almost completely.
The more I think about the whole thing, the more I am beginning to convince myself that you are both Town.
Also, what do you make of NSG’s post (#776)?
VOTE: UNVOTE
This is only to remove the temptation from MS to shut down debate.
MS is not flipping town so that won’t happen.