The logic is conflicting there, it doesn’t make sense at all how he can push those two conflicting lines of thought and then I directly asked him about and he ignored it completely
Why would you lynch me when:
You think it’s overwhelmingly likely that I am town?
Because you came back.
So you think that I’m town if I didn’t come back but since I came back you want to lynch me, but the main reason you wanted to lynch me before is because I wasn’t here day one?
Do you understand why that doesn’t make any sense to me?
If I’m misunderstanding what you’re saying please clear it up to me because that doesn’t make any sense at all so I could just not be getting whatever point you are trying to get across
The fact that you came back makes it much more likely that this is an AtE act. Not sure it is one but it makes it much more likely.
If you didn’t come back, I’d assume you were town but in that case there would be no loss from lynching you so it’d be correct unless you are literal IC.
I get how that’s circular reasoning and doesn’t give you an out but there was a scenario where I would have likely town read you without wanting to lynch you but I won’t say what that is.
Happy birthday btw
Maybe its a me-problem and I can’t fully take your threat to leave the site seriously. I remember you doing really janky oppressive AtE as scum and this is giving me flashbacks to that.
I’m sorry if I’m misinterpreting the situation but idk, this just isn’t a timeline that I can process right now.
There’s no conflicting logic
You literally just want to lynch me regardless of the scenario so yeah im done engaging with you then
Its not my birthday, its my cakeday - site signup date
Well if you look I left the discord, gave 451 fantasy football league commish status to Nanook, and have closed my random talk thread so like believe what you want to believe but after this ranked game and your game, im out. StarV doubling down on “DS is scum” even in this game just assures that.
I dont see what me being here or not being here has to do at all with this game though. I am here now, thats what should matter to you.
But yeah im not going to attempt to clear myself to someone who just wants to lynch me in every scenario they are bringing up. Thats what StarV does. It is insufferable and the reason I am having an issue with this community.
If you want to lynch me, fine, but I just hope someone level headed like Andres is still around to call you and StarV on your bullshit reasoning when I inevitably flip town.
UNVOTE
I think DS is Town. This might make me soft or whatever you want to call it but in part I don’t have much of an interest in pushing a player that is complaining about being Scum Read to the point where they are threatening to leave the community. I hold DS in high regard and if this is some plot to avoid being lynched, well then I reserve the right to policy lynch you every time you try and use this as a defense from today forward. If this is an attempt to leave in a blaze of glory, well then screw you.
At the same time, @DS it would be helpful if you could stop actively bashing everything about the game and even if you intend to never play around here going forward, help me figure out what’s happening.
I don’t think my POE is too broad, and I think my suspicion of StarV is warranted. However, he’s plainly sounding like Town to me. Which leaves me in a bit of a pickle, where I don’t want to lynch either one of the two leading wagons now. I’m going to leave GTacc and Nuxl as Town here - besides the obvious argument that bussing in that way is unlikely, I just don’t think they are coming across as Scum. So I’m going to switch it up and force Dan to come out with some solid opinions.
VOTE: ActionDan
1 Like
VOTE: ActionDan
I understand what you’re trying to get at here. However, Chess did say that you voting for everyone was interesting, but tomorrow’s problem. And he practically lolhammered Scum after arguing that Dusk’s non-existent activity was a bad look. I mean, I had him as my Top TR. So it’s not like it came as a complete surprise that he was NK’ed. So I get why you’re trying to provide meta on yourself here and you might have a point. I just think there’s plenty of reasons to think that you’re just trying to cover your ass.
Just to clarify, by sounding like Town I mean he’s not flailing everywhere or trying to divert the lynch away as hard as possible. Which you would somewhat expect from the last Scum standing. And the way he seems to be trying to help Town after their lynch seemed genuine (#372). I don’t think this is outside StarV’s Scum range by any means, but they could have tried harder to stop the lynch of Dusk D1 I think (#148, #156). Instead, they just hopped on without much resistance. It’s probably what’s giving me the most doubt about my initial read.
VOTE: ActionDan
I’m sorry you’re one of three players that could make sense here.