3 visionaries VS 10 lemmings Night 2

Completed Games Completed Onsite
#491

there’s a person im waiting for to check in and see if they claim zzz

#492

Did I catch scum on their first post elli

#493

I don’t think its that simple though tbh, even with the encryptor thing I think the pool for 3 is kinda big.
Whats the largest pool that includes the correct person that’s auto?

#494

4 technically but likely 5

#495

4 I think? Assuming one kill a night

#496

Stay frosty Gtacc

1 Like
#497

Votecount as of post #496

NotMafia (1): NotMafia

Not Voting (9): Nanook, Andresvmb, chesskid3, Zone_Q11, GTacc, Seththeking, Ellibereth, REM, JacksonVirgo

#498

So our super lazy and not double checked current POE is what, like Zone/REM/Seth/NM/Jackson, and we need to trim it down one?

#499

@bepwei this is what did it. Chess rightly questioned the reasoning behind this slight SR, and I also immediately thought it was suspect (I did the exact same thing you criticized Chess for, but I think he was still on the wagon when you made the comment and I wasn’t). When Dan flipped Scum, I looked at the above, together with you signaling your intent to hammer later in #449, as a way to try and take outsized credit for a Scum lynch that was most certainly going to happen, while downplaying the role of a player that I had a TR on.

I mean, that’s how I rationalize it. It’s also a function of gut and luck. I tend to do better at forming Town Reads that I can rely on, so it was just about shrinking the pool of players that I thought we had to run through.

2 Likes
#500

Actually neither one of us was on the wagon! Chess had just Unvoted and I did the same. The point is roughly the same.

1 Like
#501

I agree with this POE.

#502

Needs to be narrowed still

#503

I thought it was weird that he was trusting a meta read on elli that primarily came from two people he was SRing, but I wouldn’t have shot him over it :joy:

#504

Wow goddamn I forgot about that

Andres the shark man

1 Like
#505

I would not lynch NotMafia here to be honest. I actually think he’s… uhm, not Mafia.

Also, there’s a lot of noise in reads offered by Scum, but when I look at #436, it makes me not want to lynch REM.

I would lynch Zone here. I think it’s the best odds.

#506

Why tho

Like is there an actual reason to think that or

#507

Also it’s relatively common for scum to throw out three SRs that are two town and one partner. Hard for a lot of scum players to put three town as their only scum reads

#508

Whose reads were 3

#509

Bepwei

Me you REM

#510

I buy Chess’ argument. Zone made a comment about how Scum night only be able to talk at Night in #172. Dan’s role now makes that comment look highly suspicious.