11p Arsonists (1, 7)

Dan has been pretty clear town recently, lynching him because we want to give josh more of a chance is bad play. If anything lynch discussion should be between josh and starv, but I think josh is just the better option at this point

You said that you donā€™t think Josh would bury someone like this thatā€™s Town (as either alignment). Iā€™m vocally disagreeing with that.

Make your point. Donā€™t just say bro and pretend itā€™s obvious.

Oh, I see the confusion, I meant to say town!josh would probably not.

Josh isnā€™t confident enough in his scum read to go all in, Andres. I donā€™t know how you failed to figure that out from the post.

Okay so I think heā€™s wrong. Dan isnā€™t the easiest read by any means, but if this is Scum Dan Iā€™ll be somewhat surprised. Heā€™s good at surviving as Scum (heā€™s done it a few times) but I donā€™t see how he sticks his neck out like this as Scum. I donā€™t.

why are we playing armchair therapists with josh here

look at his fucking posts and decide if heā€™s scum from them lmao

1 Like

So heā€™s not going all in, but then is deflecting blame onto Nanook for starting the wagon and making long posts about why Dan is Scum? Makes no sense.

so how sure are we dan v josh contains at least 1 wolf? need to run numbers before i come to a decision

Do you think hes scum?

Itā€™s not deflecting to point out who started a wagon? Did the rest of his post give you the impression he was trying to shed blame?

Not very.

Are you serious?

We all know Iā€™m bad at reading tone, so itā€™s an honest question.

How many times is pointing out who started a wagon after being SR for making a wrong push not an attempt to shed blame?

Im p sure dan is town here, dan isnt a ballsy player from what ive seen and saying he wants him vs josh resolved rather than push the lynch onto starv is pretty outside what i would expect his scum range. That is assuming scumteam isnā€™t exactly dan+starv though, which if I think is the case, comes to light and we win easily later anyways

^

i made a mistake last game in deciding who was ballsy enough for what. i wonā€™t underestimate a player here again

Thatā€™s fair, but we donā€™t exactly know itā€™s a wrong push right now, do we?

Heā€™s backtracking, and hasnā€™t really offered up an alternative and has kept his vote down. Heā€™s also said DS is a ā€œgood voteā€, but hasnā€™t really followed through.