11p Arsonists (1, 7)

Completed Games Completed Onsite
,
#441

yet you were quite open to trusting Dusk’s read on DS at pretty much face value. And akaik that still holds over whatever independent evaluation of DS you have.

#442

Im down with starv tbh

#443

Yeah, there are some individual reads I’m willing to trust. Especially when they’re confirming my own read lol

#444

Starv/josh counterwagons please :smiley:

#445

booty

1 Like
#446

So what’s the difference in trusting reads on me vs trusting reads on DS.

Is Dusk’s read just that much better at reading DS than anyone else on reading me?

#447

I think StarV has a decent chance to flip scum but at the same time I don’t think we can afford to spend a day not lynching one of me or Josh. That really needs to be resolved as quickly as possible

#448

This is a pretty crappy position to take.

#449

And you’re voting one of my stronger townreads, so I could say the same to you.

#450

Ok so dan is town, everyone please unvote him

#451

I thought you didn’t have any meaningful reads.

#452

just because i scumread you doesn’t suddenly make my reads ‘not meaningful’

#453

Actually, in this case it does.

#454

Also, based on this post, it seems you can’t read anyone.

#455

Listen, initially I just had a feeling that something was off. But these posts make me feel a bit better about pushing Josh:

Not that I have a perfect track record at this, but I can’t really say that I would expect a Town player to behave this way. I don’t have enough history with Josh to know whether this is something he would do as Town, however, but deflecting blame in this way after making those long posts as to why Dan is Scum… I’m going to say is nonsense.

#456

br0

#457

I’m not sure I follow the first bit. You’re saying we should Town Read Dan when he sounds unreasonable, but read him as Scum when he sounds reasonable?

And Josh has powerwolfed on this site a few times now. The second bit is just provenly false.

#458

ughhh

#459

Uhmm, how is the second bit false? People not lynching him when he power wolfs doesn’t make the plan less valid.

#460

In fact, it proves the point that people could have just lynched him when he was wrong.