Well he’s already on you so seems like he’s decided?
reverse that process
Theres a scum in Andres/Josh/starv imo
why is ds lock clear, or, rather, why is josh suspicious for pushing DS?
That’s not why Josh is suspicious
This post is ok Inn a vacuum but he goes on to contradict it and later say m a town lean, but if I’m a town lean why am I in a kill pool over other people? I don’t really like his narrative at all.
Josh feels like he’s trying to set up a lynch pool that benefits him rather than solve the game, and i disagree with much of what he has said. I don’t think hes coming from a towny perspective
Also Josh’s first string of posts seems to be trying to break up the dusk/m2h/Nanook/D’s towncore that seems to be forming early. Idt Josh tried to verify or join it, he just kinda came in shading one or two and tried to break it down. If Josh is scum all four of us are pretty much clear I think.
Is Josh scum normally this obvious?
The only time I’ve ever played with him scum, me and hal had the game full solved in less than 50 posts and his partner sabotaged the game.
But he has a reputation for being good scum, I’m not really going off meta here because I don’t have much
I’m only asking bc pushing a town lean as in the kill pile is almost too bad to be bad. I feel like im missing something @Josh
Yeah Josh is definitely not bad lmao
He’s better than me anyway
Ive modded a scum game of his and it does kinda resemble what you pointed out in #231 #232 from what I remember. Though to be upfront he did sub into the scum slot so it may not be the best tell
Votecount as of post #238
Killthestory (4): Nanook, M2H, Josh, StarV
StarV (3): GTacc, tn5421, Duskfall98
DS (1): Andresvmb
Josh (1): ActionDan
Andresvmb (1): DS
Not Voting (1): Killthestory
This is kinda ignoring how a POE works. This isn’t actually contradictory—he’s leaning town on you, but you’re not as townie as other people in his eyes, not enough to be out of the POE, but enough to be at the bottom of it. That’s a consistent perspective.
1 Like
This has more legs to it. I don’t really agree I think Josh is probably town that just has a half-wrong POE, but it’s a way more reasonable stance at least.
In video he’s good but not uncatchable. Dunno that I’ve seen him play scum in forum but by reputation he’s good.
Having a light town lean still be in the POE is just…how a POE works sometimes. I don’t really think that’s a thing 
I actually would like for you to vocalize why you think I’m Scum. DS I get.
You think it’s StarV over the other two at this point?