Erika was roleblocked last night.
1 Like
If erika is town in any world or anything other than Enforcer, then YBW was not the attacking killer.
VOTE: Erika
Alrighty then, assuming Erika is the killer then, shall we attempt to find the last killer today?
what im trying to say is we shouldnt hammer erika yet
Yeah, I’m convinced you’re Spec now. There’s no way you’d have taken the chance of claiming Phone would flip Enforcer on top of guessing he’s the killer if you were anything else. I’ll vote Erika near deadline; if you had mod confirmation that the RB worked, she should be scum.
I also agree w/ YBW that we should take the time to hear her response & try to find the last killer. At the very least, we’d have more stuff to go back and read up on while trying to figure the game out later on.
I have a sinking feeling Erika is not going to help today.
Also, I was mildly impressed with the choice of Phone, but to be fair, not nearly as much as I’m impressed with the choice of Erika. Of course you took the chance to RB someone without claiming it - I expected nothing else.
I’m going to say that after claiming, the odds that YoubutWorse are Killer have probably shrank in my eyes - they would have to be the Killer who decided to withhold thinking they would actually be RB’ed, and hoping that someone else would and that it would result in a frame. Given Golden Girl’s go at it alone attitude, I’m going to guess no one would actually do this.
Yeah I mean ignore me obviously Erika needs to die. 2/3 for the Spec is actually pretty good.
Actually that logic only applies if Erika flips Town.
If Erika is the second Killer, we’re all equally likely (outside of Golden Girl) to exactly be the last shooter.
So from my POV, I have to decide who of {YoubutWorse, Luftwaffle, MartinGG99, Spak} is the last Killer provided Erika flips Scum.
I personally tr ybw
If I’m the third shooter, I have to most likely survive 2 days without drawing a shot, or the attention of the Town. So I have to completely avoid looking like the Specialist (which would have been easier here actually since Golden Girl was obvious since early D2), and also appear Town. Who fits the profile of somebody trying to slip they’re not the Specialist D1, and trying hard to solve D2 and on?
I’ll ISO the relevant players and provide my guess. It’ll probably be bad but who knows, even a broken clock is right twice a day.
This is a direct slip they’re not the Specialist.
Like what I’m thinking is - if I’m the Killer, I have to look Townie, but make sure people know I’m not the Specialist. Otherwise I run the risk of getting shot. If I’m shooting last, only the death of the second Killer gets me a shot N2 and I still have to get there.
Spak has places where they seem to hint they’re not Specialist (like the above), but it could also be interpreted as the Specialist asking for help.
This is another example of a hint, but not a direct statement.
That sounds correct XD. Before Erika is hammered, you MUST say who you’re roleblocking tonight, btw. This way, if you die, we will at least have one confirmed townie. THAT MEANS ANYONE HAMMERING BEFORE GOLDENGIRL SAYS WHO SHE’S ROLEBLOCKING TONIGHT IS DEAD TOMORROW, FOR THE RECORD.
Absolutely right: don’t execute Erika immediatly, use the time we have (even after GoldenGirl says who she roleblocks tonight).
1 Like
Here, however, Luft is adamant about not being specific about discussing what they would do as Specialist, and makes a (I am going to admit, bad attempt) at wifoming the Killers into thinking they might actually be Specialist. The obvious objective of course is to draw the shot away from the Specialist. Since they had also recommended that the Specialist Check, not RB, they would have opened themselves up to a shot.
I think the third Killer is most likely to be Spak. I don’t think the Killer would be as careless as to outright say they’re not it basically, like Youbutworse did. Only because it risks them getting executed.