Feels like it makes much more sense discussing this after we rope smilo. I’m itching to hammer.
UV
SCREEN WE HAVE VOTE TAGS NOW
1 Like
If cat is scum that means we are probably looking for one scum.
I cats town we are looking for two.
What lynch fits both criteria? I think that’s the best for today. 2 birds with one stone.
I was thinking chessbaby and judge yesterday.
But
What about judge and smile.
That’s all scum playing off town roles in some way.
Sweet.
UNVOTE:
Again, as regarding Judge, I find it more likely that chessbaby3 (who claims to have picked Elli twice) would be scum feeding nefarious info to Town, rather than having a legit Town role feeding Town-discovered info to scum. So I’d pick Judge over chessbaby3 in that scenario.
The primary advantage I see of cat being scum is that he suicided to save screenplay, where screen would have been a scum inventor who needed to be saved. But then imo screen also comes into focus in there being too many Doctor possibilities. We know Dan was Town JOAT, so I think it likely one of screen or GiF are not Town. They each have elements of Town or scum play, but I think one of them is a good choice for today.
I agree smilodon may be scum, but we learn more helpful info I think in deciding elsewhere, either in lynching chessbaby3, or one of screen or GiF.
I think screenscum shoots me over erika n1 everytime.
From what all was said I think scum had a reasonable guess Erika was a twofer.
Chesskid was a twofer on exactly and only N2.
Erika wasn’t a twofer N1 and we’re discussing N1.
hmm in that case my money is on screen being scum.
historically, do your mafia games work out to be so meta-solvable?
mmm if I’m smart about it yeah.
In this case I think screenscum in particular would easily be the most intimidated by me. I think he would even confirm this fact. 
(Like look at the sheer amount of people who targetted me N1…there’s a reason).
How did you guys reach the one of GiF or screen thing? Between those two GiF is obviously 20 thousand times more town but idk how that dichotomy happened.
that was pyx’s thinking and if they’re town this is the first thing I can pay attention to.
I believe GIF to be town and would never lynch them
with all the claims out, my claim is weak but it’d be a stupid risk to declare the night actions on you
I’m still happy with smilodon. Meta tells me to doubt that it could be both smilodon and pyx due to the full-on defending of pyx that smilodon was doing earlier.
Probably one thing is I can hardly remember anything Gif has said but Screenplay stands out as having been vocal through the game and also seeming to be scum hunting. Which may not be fair on Gif, but when playing with a lot of new Names you first take note of the most visible.
If you’re scum I’ll eat a hat.
damnit I want to see that!
VC 4-6
smilodon: 3 (Judge Mental, ellibereth, Alisae, )
Not Voting: 5 (pyx, GuyinFreezer, smilodon, chessbaby3, Srceenplay)
Deadline: April 5, Noon US Eastern Time
Autolock Timer set to 30 minutes after Day 3 deadline is at the bottom of the thread
With 8 Alive it takes 5 to majority-lynch
Links:
Day 1 Begins
Day 1 Ends
Day 2 Begins
Day 3 Begins
Day 4 Begins
So who really thinks chessbaby3 is town at this point? It seems everyone is arguing for the towniness of players, but then there’s chessbaby.
how often does scum get a watcher role? curious
Not often? But it’s easy to have a role that can be manipulated to look like a town role. You know I’ve done it often enough. If you were a scum blocker, for example, you could quite easily say ‘so and so was visited’ and the victim would be all ‘yeah I couldn’t do my action!’
nah, they are definitely a watcher, unless you think they and I are both scum