This doesn’t help sort Josh though if he was converted N1 correct?
1 Like
I’m sock. I am going to keep the mystery alive
Frankly, what I’m most concerned about is that it’s entirely possible that neither one of you was the convert, and this whole thing results in a waste of two days and all of us dead. I can’t figure out why Elli as Scum would place himself in this crappy position because if you flip Town he’s getting my vote immediately. And if you flip Scum he’s guaranteed to die, unless he’s bussing you and that would be completely ridiculous, since he created this whole situation to begin with.
Hunting for the converted person is open wolfing when judging by the numbers, there’s 2 wolves left to find who started on the wolf team. The people my slot targeted have extremely low wolf equity as they can only be the converted person. I can also just read Josh as I played with him a bunch and I feel strongly he’s a villager. If people want to evaluate him on later days that’s fine, but today we are looking for wolves.
It should also be obvious if anyone is playing the day like they got converted into a wolf, it’s Elli…
I would be advocating to lynch neither of them if Elli wasn’t open wolfing.
And why does Rich get such a strong role and I get such a crap one? He’s an unlimited cop or a doctor that is killed when protecting Scum? And why would you gamble on someone when you can just cop them first and not risk your own life (which destroys any information you might have)? I don’t know it seems way overpowered but I suck at this sort of thing so I’ll wait on other opinions.
maybe he’s fake 
He’s trading 1 for 1 because he’s salty about not being able to win with town. Imagine being in his shoes, stomping the wolf team just to become one. Wouldn’t it mess with your emotional state causing you to play unconventional lines?
I instantly die if I target a wolf. Now that I claimed I can’t even use it anymore. It’s far from good
i explicitly told the doctor not to protect me
and it was super unlikely for me to be targeted by town and super likely to be targeted by scum otherwise sooo
If I cop a wolf I die. It does risk my life.
I disagree. You can loudly proclaim who you are going to gamble on and if you die we’ve hit Scum. Seems like a great trade-off. And if you don’t but are NK’ed wouldn’t that be obvious too? Well sure the Scum Team could withhold the kill but would they? With the way this is going I wouldn’t.
Ah sorry I misread that.
He’s been softing a josh green peek all day, but idk how the order would resolve if he was converted the same night.
Every time I’ve seen a role like this in a setup, the wolves have been able to re-direct. I’m very confident they have a bus-driver or a re-directer to counteract me doing that.
they’re
just
both
scum
Rich’s stance on me just isn’t real but I don’t want to argue with him about it. 
Nah never mind there’s too many strategic issues with you announcing it now that I think about it.
inb4 rich is another suicide converter.
Yeah they could both be Scum, sure. But then that leaves what 1 left to be found? Seems incredibly suboptimal to come out strong to defend Josh if that’s the case.
look at what happened d1. 
and I don’t think its suboptimal here, both he and Josh are super strong rhetorically and can just bulldoze the town with words. Like imagine if I weren’t causing a shitstorm here. I think they believe they can have Josh talk his way out of dying if I flip first.