SoDope Mafia Eleven

Completed Games Completed Onsite
#821

Fake

#822

I’m trying to figure out your angle here, I’m coming up with two possibilities:

  1. You are trying to strong-arm this to show how amazing you are at this game and you don’t even have to take the sure thing because your “read” is a sure thing (and it’s wrong)
  2. You think this is a multiball game and you want to give yourself town cred as scum

In any case, you’re either overconfident or you’re scum.

#823

There’s a lot more than this but this should already be sufficient

  1. The claims are that StarV (mason recruiter) recruited MS.
  2. MS would have had a role prior to being recruited.
  3. He forgot about 2) because he wasn’t mason recruited.
#824

MS, as claimed, is a vanilla Mason.
Elli vs MS is not SvS imo.
Ergo, it doesn’t matter which of the two we lynch today, the one flipping scum makes the other conf town.

So knock off the BS about optimal play, optimal play is to lynch whichever of them I think is scum. Elli as town is also more useful than MS as town, so if you want to talk about optimal play it isn’t optimal to lynch Elli here.

The claims don’t add up, we are lynching MS here and if hits town I will laugh at him.

#825

we could also lynch chesskid because lolcounterwagon

#826

Okay fuck it lets see if I hilariously hard defend scum!MS and scum!Elli here

1 Like
#827

You know Josh has been doing a lot better job at the pushing than I have right. :stuck_out_tongue:
(In general he’s probably just straight up way better than me in playerlists like this one).

But yeah, “Hey I suspect this guy and then claims that make no sense with tons of holes and inconsistencies happened let’s keep’em pushing” isn’t overconfidence lmao.

#828

It is when you can get a confirmation that we’re town by waiting till tomorrow.

#829

21st century gimme that instant gratification

#830

Actually, it doesn’t matter. regardless what happens, I’m dead town right now. I’ll see you all at the reveal, there’s little point to me arguing this case when I have 0% chance of being alive tomorrow.

#831

Also, didn’t someone claim that there was little chance of their being a rolecop when Josh had already claimed JOAT?

I’m running under the assumption that he’s got a rolecop ability. Anyway, 0% chance a mafia team makes this play, it’s just absurd.

#832

Except when scum roleblock you and keep you alive for wifom :o

#833

No that’s just what hes gonna say tomorrow

#834

Golly goodness gracious me who could have foreseen it?

#835

I mean, Elli already hinted at you two being scum together, so I don’t really know what to say here.

Maybe Golly Gee?

#836

Are u reading the thread bro

#837

BRooooooooooooo, I totally didn’t think that was a necessary part of Mafia

#838

K well elli didnt hint at me being scum so

But idk why I am engaging u

#839

I do

#840

We are lynching MS today.
If it flips town, we are lynching Elli tomorrow. Possibly Chess day 3.
If it flips scum, we lynch StarV day 2.

This is the plan. Any objections?