Sock or Geyde seem fine fallbacks to me
1 Like
Sock because his tune changed from last night and geyde because what
sock voted for MS until now though and I can understand the jump ship that happened.
No opinion on Geyde, never figured out what you disliked about.
I had a tune?
idk I think safest outside the scumplet is probably Tier (I think I said that earlier?)
A bunch of relevant people are all contingent on how they turn out.
idk just from an information pov staying on the scumplet seems right? roles are overrated.
Lynch MS
town = kill Elli
scum = kill StarV
this seems pretty simple?
Honestly, this just seems like scum plans went wrong. Like, you’re so focused on a lynch and then you’re like “well fuck, I have no clue what to do now…”
I really don’t see how anyone reacts that way as town.
VOTE: Ellibereth
Call be a sceptic, how does this lynch order make any sense?
I’ve reacted EXACTLY this way as town before too… stop posting stuff that is just wrong lmao
I don’t play a lot of forum mafia, can you tell?
VOTE: MetalSonic ok boys
I scum read both of you. Elli scum reads both of you. We both have generally very good reads, though Elli better than mine. Your claims are very convoluted. Ergo, we lynch MS as the not-recruiter to resolve.
If it flips town? Great, Elli is very likely scum, and we lynch him next. 1 mason for 1 scum is a fine trade.
If it flips scum? Great, StarV is confirmed scum, and we lynch him next.
I think MS is more likely scum so he gets lynched before Elli, and lynching outside of all 3 means scum never has to resolve it for us.
Pretty sure town has already lost.
1 Like
Alright, well I can’t go with my biggest scum read because you’re lynching conf town, I basically have to go with the next highest vote count.
VOTE: chesskid3
There are many better ways a town!MS could have played this that would’ve made me reconsider.
He could’ve claimed mason with StarV from the beginning and dropped the recruit part altogether. Scum will never randomly block a mason as they almost always lack roles.
He could’ve claimed mason with StarV and claimed he was the recruiter and strongwilled (unblockable). Then people would’ve been more likely to target him than StarV if at all
Hell, he could’ve claimed a factional recruit either of them could do that would be a 50/50 which is better than this.
Claiming “I am not the mason recruiter” is never the right play.
He claimed that he was the recruiter at first? Cool, then he should’ve kept that up and claimed his partner. Or, at the very least, kept his fucking fake claim straight and not fallen to my role name test. It was a simple fucking test.
Now, if he’s town, he’s put me in the position where I can’t solve the game without his flip. And I am lynching him here mostly because I think he’s scum, but partially to teach him to listen to me when I talk mechanics in the future if he’s town.
So yes, I think lynching MS here is still the right play.
2 Likes
Then do it
I am doing it.
There’s a set of people who I think “are very wrong about theory/strategy but I can see where they’re coming from” that include Margaret…and some other people. I swear there are others. (Mittens I think?). So I think their interaction wrt this MS/StarV stuff when “how to act based on the role claim is involved” is moot regardless of flip
I’m actually not sure what either MS flip means for Erika. I think the hard align (pre and post claim) is at around base probability for all alignment permutations there.
Geyde is in a weird spot where people keep suggesting him but there’s no half decent reason?
MS scum => sock town I think because he could have found an excuse to get off a lot earlier. The time he chose to get off was actually pretty reasonable.
I think it’s just me pushing Geyde tbh
also if MS was recruited doesn’t that mean he should have had an original role lmao.