And that would offend you how? Literally been calling you Scum the entire game. And Rich has him as Scum. Like, what?
Haha the confirmed Town. No such thing buddy.
Confirmed from my pov anyway … .
I’m not offended one bit. I’m trying to figure out what you meant by “But if I could, it would be a win for Town.”
You’re so sure that it’s JohnnyDollar and not Sock?
I’m just trying to figure out what your winning play is for town.
@Andresvmb im awake for about 5 more minutes
regardless of sock’s alignment, he is the best lynch today. tell me why i’m wrong as you so firmly believe.
simple exercise.
Ha! I’ve been training for this my whole life
The lynch target is irrelevant since we all agree it’s gonna be governed (Sock proving their role)
It might as well be Sock in case they are lying about the role.
SDMXI - Day 5
Votecount as of post #2065
Sock (3): Mittens, RichParente, Josh
Rich Parente (1): JohnnyDollar
JohnnyDollar (1): Andresvmb
Not Voting (3): sock, Tier, Margaret
With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Plurality is in effect.
Deadline is: 2019-03-23T16:00:00Z
Alright let’s let him govern. And if he’s lying so be it.
But if he is telling the truth, it still doesn’t say much about his alignment. And nobody is making a case against based on anything more than his role. I actually tried looking beyond that.
Dude you do know that I can’t be sure of anything unless I’m Scum right? Stop being obnoxious.
How can anyone make this case seriously? Of course the target and the Day matters. If Sock is Scum, why would he govern anything other than the lynch of Scum, unless it’s blatantly obvious that he’s interfering in such a way?
My guess is that if sock is Scum, he’s lying about his role in some way.
You’re the one who said town would win if they listened to you…
This is a joke, right?
Andres -> foot in mouth
Fuck off.
So this is a joke? You’re scum aren’t you.
Is this how you typically play Mafia? You ask players if they’re Scum and if they say yes you vote for them? How often does that work?
Ok I’ll slow it down for you.
This reads to me that you’re confident you have a correct read on the game right now, and with your vote on JohnnyDollar that means we should move that direction (from your point of view).
I then clarify that this is really the case.
And then you respond with this…
So it looks to me like you’re waffling back and forth between being confident you can lead town to a win, but then also saying that you can’t be sure of anything unless you’re scum…
Wait so you actually spent time separating quotes about how I think I could potentially lead Town to victory, though I’m obviously not sure as nothing is guaranteed, but spent no time analyzing my interaction with Rich at all?
It’s more telling to me, so I put more effort into these reactions from you.
I’m good on my analysis for now.
I think it’s Sock as original scum and Andres as the recruit.
You put more effort into stupid comments instead of actually reading the game? Gotcha.
And you’re wrong about me. You can try and project as much confidence as you want about how I’m sure Scum and then act all surprised when I don’t flip Scum, but it really is in front of your face. You seem to think that anyone who doesn’t just go with the flow is Scum, when all I’m trying to do is actually figure out what is going on. And you acting all high and mighty when almost everything you’ve supported this game has been wrong is amazing to me. In case you needed a reminder:
I had forgotten that I’ve been wrong quite a bit. Thanks for the reminder